Uh, you make this fair by letting the trans child play. This "juggernaut" team in Vermont with the trans player was 12-6 in Division 4 and got destroyed in the game after they won by forfeit against the 3-10 Karen team. The Karen team was so bad that Maxpreps says it is the fifth worst girls' basketball team in the entire state of Vermont. Given that Vermont may be the worst state in the country for basketball, the Karen team is probably one of the 20 worst girls basketball teams in the entire US.
There is no proof of an "unfair" advantage here. This is all about a bs Christian school grandstanding with its anti-LGBTQ agenda in a game that they were going to lose anyway, and which they would have lost to roughly 16,980 of 17,000 HS basketball teams in the United States. Given that a trans girls can't even move the needle in the Vermont D4 girls basketball playoffs, it is pretty clear that all of your transphobic fears that elite male athletes will "go trans" and ruin girls sports forever is completely unfounded. If they want fairness, they need to stop blaming a trans girl and instead take responsibility for the fact that their fat lazy asses are the real reason they're terrible.
So just to be clear….
1. You really don’t think the Trans Young Lady has a physiological advantage over her Biological Female competitors, is that correct?
2. Or, If you do think there is an advantage, you don’t think it matters because the teams are non-competitive in the grand scheme of high school basketball in that state, is that correct?
So who decides when the competitiveness of the event matters enough? Only D1 HS???
If you have ever heard the sayings “if you give someone an inch, they will take a yard, or death by a million cuts”…when you crack the door it sometimes gets blown wide open.
This is where the discussion gets challenging, you think people like me who have a different perspective are blaming the trans girl. I don’t blame her, I’m positive she and her family are dealing with a lot. I’m sure she just wants to play. I blame the Woke Politicians, School Districts, States, Governing Bodies, etc. for allowing the participation in competitive sports where an individual(s) has a distinct physiological advantage. Allowing Biological Males to participate in Biological Female sports takes opportunities away from Biological Females. Allowing it because of the way somebody feels, identifies, due to Dysphoria, etc., etc., does not change the fact that the Trans Girl is a Biological Male who has physiological advantages. Biological Females should not have opportunities taken away because somebody is more comfortable or feels better playing and being with opposite sex.
We talked about Coed Sports, I worked at an indoor soccer facility as a Teenager, ran the scoreboard…we had Coed Adult Leagues…Men had to play 2 touch on shooting plays, could only score from behind a line, and then only from a pass from a women, and had to have 3 women on the field at all times, why do you think rules like this were in place? To ensure Biological Males did not dominate the game, and to create a fair playing field. How do you create fair and equitable in Team Sports with Biological Males and Females competing on the same team without changing the rules of the game. You can’t. It is forcing Biological Females to just deal with it, live with it, and just accept it. Just does not seem right for them to give up opportunities. Individual sports are different and think that can be solved…team sports are different animals. This whole issue is very unique to the mtf vs ftm.
www.concordmonitor.com
