Vaccine

Or when everyone realized school choice was being co-opted by billionaires (Kochs, etc) to privatize education.

There was a time when this country believed in a strong public education system. I guess we don't anymore -- and it shows. The problem isn't inherent to public schools, it's what we as a country deem important to invest in. God knows there's billion examples of corrupt charter schools.
And yet if a charter does bad it goes away.

That doesn't happen with public schools.

Every time I see a charter open in a less than desirable area I think how lucky the kids are to finally have a better option.
 
I was at Silverlakes this weekend , stayed at a hotel .

The hotel was completely booked, and Id estimate 90% were there because of soccer. Id say the majority of the soccer people were from LA and San Diego. There we a lot of parents and teams hanging out in the lobby at night , and I actually chatted with some people who were from LA. Almost no one was wearing a mask .

I wonder if LA peeps feel a sense of freedom when they get out of the county, because I certainly didn't walk away from this weekend thinking that they were somehow more frightened of covid than other people or wouldn't they be wearing a mask?

We also played 2 LA teams this weekend, and I didn't see a single parent on their sidelines ( nor any players ) wearing mask.

Just something I noticed, because my perception was that mask compliance was extremely high for people who reside in LA.

I think they are underestimating the powder keg they are sitting on. If there are more pictures of adults partying at the Superbowl and kids need to go to LAUSD in masks the next day, I think they will be facing a full on parent rebellion. No wonder they are hiring all that extra security to enforce the mask requirements.
 
Link about what, corrupt charter schools? For real? Took two seconds to find this:


It goes on and on and on....
And then you see public school districts producing the following.


And reading your article above it seems less the fault of charter schools and far more of how the government vetts prospective schools and how gov fails to do oversight.

Which is typical and which is why public schools in many areas underperform decade after decade.
 
I think they are underestimating the powder keg they are sitting on. If there are more pictures of adults partying at the Superbowl and kids need to go to LAUSD in masks the next day, I think they will be facing a full on parent rebellion. No wonder they are hiring all that extra security to enforce the mask requirements.

starting To think this is a small but vocal minority that aren’t able to move on

I know Twitter isn’t an accurate representation of the public at large , but read the replies to Newsom tweet yesterday announcing the mask mandates are going away. There are certainly people who never want mask mandates to go away
 
What do vaxxes do now? They don't stop the spread. So no need for them in that aspect.

They still offer some protection to those at risk.

And then that leaves those that choose not to take the vax.

WHen you look at the above, there is no need to mandate masks or vaxxes.
What do vaccines do? For starters, they reduce your odds of getting covid by a factor of six.

That also reduces your odds of spreading covid by a factor of six. Slightly more, because a vaccinated person is also infectious for a shorter time.

So, no. The vaccine doesn't 'stop' transmission. It just reduces transmission by 90% or so.

Incidentally, a 90% reduction in transmission is the difference between "huge case spike" and "minor outbreaks here and there."
 
What do vaccines do? For starters, they reduce your odds of getting covid by a factor of six.

That also reduces your odds of spreading covid by a factor of six. Slightly more, because a vaccinated person is also infectious for a shorter time.

So, no. The vaccine doesn't 'stop' transmission. It just reduces transmission by 90% or so.

Incidentally, a 90% reduction in transmission is the difference between "huge case spike" and "minor outbreaks here and there."
I think your numbers are wildly overestimated especially since we know the double vaxx simply isn’t that efficient in stopping omicron (remember the party in Neatherlands superspreader event was caused by a vaccinated individual in a room full of vaccinated people) and even with boosters the efficiency is declining with time. If it were 90% that many people would simply not have gotten ill at that event.

further highly vaxxed countries have all had omicron spikes..they were just less severe but hardly an outbreak here and there

but even assuming arguendo your 90%…you never answer why you care…the unvaxxed have made their decision and the vaccine is suppose to protect against serious illness. Who you protecting here? Just wanna avoid the bad cold?
 
I think your numbers are wildly overestimated especially since we know the double vaxx simply isn’t that efficient in stopping omicron (remember the party in Neatherlands superspreader event was caused by a vaccinated individual in a room full of vaccinated people) and even with boosters the efficiency is declining with time. If it were 90% that many people would simply not have gotten ill at that event.

further highly vaxxed countries have all had omicron spikes..they were just less severe but hardly an outbreak here and there

but even assuming arguendo your 90%…you never answer why you care…the unvaxxed have made their decision and the vaccine is suppose to protect against serious illness. Who you protecting here? Just wanna avoid the bad cold?

@dad4 tries to manipulate numbers to defend his out of touch reality…he can not stand being wrong. Even when every vaccinated person he knew got Covid over winter break he still wants to blame it on the unvaccinated. Maybe the world is flat?
 
What do vaccines do? For starters, they reduce your odds of getting covid by a factor of six.

That also reduces your odds of spreading covid by a factor of six. Slightly more, because a vaccinated person is also infectious for a shorter time.

So, no. The vaccine doesn't 'stop' transmission. It just reduces transmission by 90% or so.

Incidentally, a 90% reduction in transmission is the difference between "huge case spike" and "minor outbreaks here and there."

vaxx appears to have held up great against omicron in NYC. for cases even. rate per 100K is cases vaxx/vaxx and cases novaxx/novaxx, ie correctly normalized to meaningfully compare the rates. https://www1.nyc.gov/site/doh/covid/covid-19-main.page

Screen Shot 2022-01-25 at 11.56.34 AM.png
 
I think your numbers are wildly overestimated especially since we know the double vaxx simply isn’t that efficient in stopping omicron (remember the party in Neatherlands superspreader event was caused by a vaccinated individual in a room full of vaccinated people) and even with boosters the efficiency is declining with time. If it were 90% that many people would simply not have gotten ill at that event.

further highly vaxxed countries have all had omicron spikes..they were just less severe but hardly an outbreak here and there

but even assuming arguendo your 90%…you never answer why you care…the unvaxxed have made their decision and the vaccine is suppose to protect against serious illness. Who you protecting here? Just wanna avoid the bad cold?
The 1:6 ratio is not an estimate. It's the vax to unvax ratio of positive tests per Capita.

You may not like it, but it's still true. Most covid cases are unvaccinated. And, as a result, most covid transmission is coming from unvaccinated people, too.

Why do I care? About 900,000 Americans have died of this. Another 2000 each day. That is who we could have been protecting, but decided not to.
 
The 1:6 ratio is not an estimate. It's the vax to unvax ratio of positive tests per Capita.

You may not like it, but it's still true. Most covid cases are unvaccinated. And, as a result, most covid transmission is coming from unvaccinated people, too.

Why do I care? About 900,000 Americans have died of this. Another 2000 each day. That is who we could have been protecting, but decided not to.

short of literal government force , how do you suggest we protect the unvaccinated from dying ?
 
short of literal government force , how do you suggest we protect the unvaccinated from dying ?
The unvaccinated are not the only ones dying.

There are also covid deaths among vaccinated people with weakened immune systems or other health issues. Maybe 10% or so of deaths?

The health care libertarians here don't like to talk about that part.
 
The unvaccinated are not the only ones dying.

There are also covid deaths among vaccinated people with weakened immune systems or other health issues. Maybe 10% or so of deaths?

The health care libertarians here don't like to talk about that part.

that’s all true , but you didn’t really answer the question

so how do we protect those people in the 10% category ?
 
that’s all true , but you didn’t really answer the question

so how do we protect those people in the 10% category ?
The unvaccinated are not the only ones dying.

There are also covid deaths among vaccinated people with weakened immune systems or other health issues. Maybe 10% or so of deaths?

The health care libertarians here don't like to talk about that part.
At least we know what we are debating now. The relevant subject is the 10%.

and the relevant question is to what extent are we going to reorganize society to protect that 10%. Certainly things should be reorganized particularly in nursing homes to the extent they need to be protected and inconvenienced. But when you are talking kids being inconvenieced that’s a totally different story.

I have skin in the game on this for 3 generations and a god child in the 4th. For my parents I totally see it justified that they should get boosted and wear 95s and limit their social activities. For me it is reasonable even having had it to get vaxxed. For my 20 year old goddaughter she is not at risk and youth is too fleeting to restrict her life any further particularly with the authoritarian rules at some colleges. For my kids it is monstrous to insist they continue to sacrifice their childhood for the sake of my parents.

we don’t reorganize society for flu. We don’t do it for rsv where kids are vulnerable. We certainly shouldn’t for the glass staff 10%
 
starting To think this is a small but vocal minority that aren’t able to move on

I know Twitter isn’t an accurate representation of the public at large , but read the replies to Newsom tweet yesterday announcing the mask mandates are going away. There are certainly people who never want mask mandates to go away
How many do you think are Members of an activist group funded by the Newsome Re-Election fund?
 
vaxx appears to have held up great against omicron in NYC. for cases even. rate per 100K is cases vaxx/vaxx and cases novaxx/novaxx, ie correctly normalized to meaningfully compare the rates. https://www1.nyc.gov/site/doh/covid/covid-19-main.page

View attachment 12865

Um, what are you trying to convey?

The reporting bias of those without risk or symptoms in the absence of mandatory testing?

Or.. that a sliver of the population is more likely to get infected by a virus novel to their immune system sans vaccination or prior infection.

Both should appear obvious to all adults, if not… well, Darwin’s theory will work things out in the end.
 
Back
Top