@Grace T. in one of your posts, you mentioned that you agreed with me that kids should not be making these transition decisions too early in life. I think you said under 18 if I am not mistaken.
If that is the case, wouldn’t it be better for these children and young people to continue to play sports based on their Biological Sex rather than their Gender Identity until they are mature enough to make those forever decisions?
You also mentioned scholarships and things at schools related to Title IX. It is currently based on Biological Sex, not Gender. How do you propose this occurs? For the revenue producing sports at Universities, Football and Basketball, Trans Men would have little or no opportunities to participate. Even Soccer, Baseball, Hockey, Rugby it would be difficult for a Trans Man to participate in those sports. For Women’s College athletics which are not revenue producing, with limited scholarships, and the landscape that will certainly change over the next few years giving the NCAA less oversight, and Mega Conferences being created, it’s going to put a squeeze on team funding at universities. Are you saying we should have Men’s, Women’s, Trans Women’s, and Trans Men’s Sports? Or have Coed Teams? Trans Teams?
How do you legislate and manage 100’s of genders, scholarships, to be inclusive of every single permutation. Where do you draw the line? There will always be some unrepsented or underrepresented group as Gender seems to be a very fluid prospect and people can and have changed their Gender.
This may offend people, and I apologize. Biological Males and Females are not equal or the same physically…reproductive organs, skeletal and muscularity differences, etc. We all learned this in Biology. This has not changed in the last few years. It’s why you can test bones and find out the Biological Sex, but you can’t test for how somebody feels, thinks, or identifies. The science has not changed and it can’t be changed because of how somebody feels or identifies or believes. Physics has not changed, Chemistry has not changed. The sciences are objective, not subjective.
I truly feel for people who are going through this, and believe as you said they need safe spaces, kindness, and respect. It’s a tough road. I also think everyone should have the same opportunities in life. That said, Biological Males should not be competing against Biological Females in sports. There are unfair physical advantages, and safety concerns that at this point in time can’t be evened.