I've got good news and bad news for you if you decide to stick with club soccer (and given everything you've said you may not want to). Good news first. If your kids is passionate about it and willing to put in the work, as he advances in age and level it gets better. The parents begin to relax a bit and realize the scores just aren't that important. The coaches aren't under as much tremendous pressure to win. You get a better class of referee. That said, it's not going to be perfect (they threatened to jump my kid a few weeks back and he needed a security escort).I am sorry you had to deal this. I have dealt with it myself being called all kind of names and my daughter had to deal with it from some parents and kids when she was 3 in pre-school. We have been talking to them about this since they both hit 3 years old. This is not just in America but all over the world. How we deal with here is just different.
My definition of competition is both tied to fair and balanced matches and declaring a champion. SOCAL doesnt flight any team, the clubs and coaches can elect to place their team in any flight they want. SOCAL only brackets them after you chose the age/flight registration. Thats partially why we have the lopsided matches. No oversight on teams prior performance.
This feels a little like a cop out. The refs hands are not tied, the refs just refuse to act in my experience. On top of that the league refuses to take action even with video evidence. Saying the league doesnt have power is also untrue as they can easily suspend the coach/club or even do more but they CHOOSE to do nothing. The bigger scandal than Socal Elite and more so harm will happen when a team/parents/club decide to SoCal Soccer League to the cleaners for inaction and misdirection of referees. I suspect that isnt far away given the way these games are being refereed.
That isnt how you count hourly pay. You only get paid for the time you are on the clock. 2 games - 140 minutes (30 minutes 2x halves and 10 min half time) = $56.57 and hour, i rounded when i said 60 an hour. When you go to work you dont start your 8 hour day from the time you leave your door to the time you get back home to calculate your hourly pay. Similarly you cant count the time in between games. I worked as a referee for 4 years through college in SoCal. Refereeing youth and adult leagues. I did this at a much lower rate as it was 20 years ago and i was still making a couple grand a month with it being a side gig. Yes the shortage is real and maybe we need to pay more but while we have incompetence being allowed and supplied by the league who is going to pay more?
From March of this year our team has suffered 2x concussions, 5x intentional stamps on the face (which we have on tape with coach complementing his players on it) and numerous dangerous plays (not clumsy - i am discounting those completely) egged on by the teams coach and parents. These are just the physical injuries. The ones that are worse are the psychological ones from what the opposition coaches and parents yell. I do not define referee/league inaction as limited to physical injuries but psychological and physical. At this age the phycological damage can be far worse than any physical injury that the other player can inflict. Also i am not just saying this on behalf of my child/team but on behalf of those parets like some have mentioned fear their kid being benched, not fully aware of their options or the odd one out on the team that notices the issue but is in the minority to speak up.
Completely agree and we have done that. This doesnt solve the problem though when you are playing in a league and then tournaments where the same teams come up against you. You can chose to forfeit but that only benefits the guilty team. Action should and needs to be taken / forced to be taken by the league or tournament host in each of these cases. But if everyone refuses to document and take action the subsequent host can be provided with previous documentation of the problem.
This eventual sale profit was made illegal in EU for contracts signed by parents on behalf of minors. I described this in some detail earlier. Clubs can have the same profit/commitment structure in the US as well as seen by the Kimbraugh contract at 13. Just because clubs havent caught on or chose not that shouldnt be used as an excuse. At the end of the day i am not faulting the clubs as i have stated on multiple occasions for being capitalist but i am saying the League needs to be better at regulation on several fronts.
This is the first i have heard of the red card list but cannot seem to find it anywhere on the site. If you have a link that would be great. The question is it even being enforced. At least 1 out 4 referees dont even bother verify player cards let alone check coach/parent cards in 7vs7.
The bad news is in the immediate future it's going to get worse. It's not a rare technique to see more unskilled teams lash out at more skilled teams as a way to keep the score level. There are systems of play, such as the Mexican style, that rely on physicality. There's a certain school of ref, called the "let 'em play" school, that doesn't believe the game should be overly disrupted for fouls that are trifling and they consider soccer a naturally physical game. The refs are overworked and don't want to find themselves in the middle of things with more paperwork when they are struggling just to go from game to game. The leagues are worried about lawsuits, and are reluctant to take action against their customers (which are the clubs, not the players) unless something is really egregious (again more paperwork, for which they don't have the staff, because they'll always be another side to the story that fights the ruling). Your kid will be called the N word, especially in southern California, again not frequently but also not rarely, sometimes from surprising directions (such as people of color and not just white people)...they'll say it in a way the ref doesn't overhear or in a way so the ref doesn't stop the game for a card. Many of the refs don't have the skill to manage a contentious game, which can quickly accelerate from minor fouls, to increasingly harder ones, to fights between players and even parents (yes there are now zero policy rules but it hasn't stopped it completely). The boys are going to get more mass, and their fuses shorter when the testosterone starts flowing. And the bad coaches are everywhere and if your kid is a skilled player that makes a difference in the game, they can be targeted...moreover the boys get more clever about the types of dirty play they can get away with or how to inflict maximum pain as they get smarter.
Worth it? Certainly not to me. Have been trying to get my player to quit for years. From the list of your many complaints (some of which is just impatience, or railing against certain difficult realities that you are just beginning to see as a newb, but this one in particular I regard as pretty legit), it may not be the right thing for you, and as others have pointed out, there are better options.