This is 2004.
Are you talking about Condliffe?
Because if you are talking about him I assume you know the 2003 revolted against having him which is why Tonks took over?
I also assume the fact that condliffe lost five players (three or which for concerns over favoritism) had him posting here for players in Nov?
I also assume you know that his frequent abscences due to medical issues would create concerns?
Listen I am not emotional at all. This is fact based information.
This is a coach who was not wanted by an older group, had significant retention issues.
As for Pauley evaluating you- no. He evaluated one of you.
Again sorry to rain on the parade but if he was evaluating any B team why did he extend offers to Blues players, LAGSD and some Strikers? Why did he transfer PRE STATE CUP three more players on to his team?
That does not show loyalty not that he "cares".
Surf recruits from outside, not a B team
Yes, my DD does play on GC’s 04 Team which just ended tonight when we lost 0 to 1 to Duggan’s team in Nationals. I have heard about GC’s 03 team, but I can’t respond as I don’t have first-hand knowledge. I can just give you first-hand experience from one family that played for GC’s 04 team this past year.
I can’t speak for all of our parents, but I feel pretty confident that the majority of our parents and girls liked Gary as a coach and felt we had a great season in which are girls developed. Yes, we had a great group of skilled girls, but our coach certainly played a big role.
I can tell you that every girl on our team practiced with Pauly’s Team on a continual basis at different points throughout the season. Maybe you don’t call that evaluation, but Pauly has coached our team during practices and has filled in for a few games, so I do think that all of our girls have had a fair look. Yes, one of our players got a better look and had the opportunity to play on Pauly’s team during a tournament or two and CRL, but Pauly has looked at all of our girls. If you don’t want to call that evaluation fine, we can play semantics and say he only evaluated 1 girl on our team.
Your information that we lost 5 players is incorrect. We had 15 players (2 of which are full time keepers) and we lost 1 player giving us only 12 field players, so yes GC was probably looking for more players in Nov and yes we did pickup 3 new players before Nationals.
My point to Alone was pretty simple. Look at all the information, but take it all with a grain of salt. After all, it is all just opinion (including mine). Maybe what happened with GC’s 03 team carries some weight, but so should the fact that many parents had a great season with GC on his 04 team.
I can tell you that Striker17, mentioned a team that Alone should look at while saying don’t look at Surf or Sharks. Based on first-hand experience, I would never recommend any girl ever play for that particular coach. I hold that coach in very low regard. But I know 3 families that love that coach and their daughters love that coach. I would never state on a public forum that a player should avoid a coach or a team because of my opinion.
The reality is every soccer family and player has different goals, different personalities, and are looking for different things. While a particular club or coach might not be a good fit for some families it might be the perfect fit for other families. Blanket statements that any teams should be avoided are simply biased. Maybe my daughter could make a lot of A teams out there, but for the quality of our B team, this is one family that is perfectly happy to be on GC’s B team next year.