Vaccine

dad4 said:
Suppose a low skill trans kid wants to try rec soccer. Born male, lives as female, no real soccer skills.

Who is harmed if they join a girls rec team?

The kind thing to do is to accommodate their request.
Click to expand...

Younger rec teams are often coed anyway.
 
dad4 said:
Chromosome count? It works, but it is overkill. There are very few people for whom their chromosomes do not match the gender identified at birth.
Just use original birth certificates, and have a process for appeal based on DNA.

If you have a better definition, state it.


Not quite. But the politics lens was the easiest way to help you see how your position looks.

The women athletes affected by this have a valid point. It deserves to be heard instead of just calling people “fixed-minded” or “transphobe”.
Click to expand...
I just see scared people reacting to things they seem to see through the lens they have been given. Not sure if many in here have said anything about trans rights only that they are cheating somehow? I pretty much agree with your opening paragraph, but who is to say that isn’t what has happened already? Do we know this all just based on what the potential athletes say or has there been testing of some kind? Just not a fan of fear based on biases.
 
MicPaPa said:
How brave of you to admit they had a point, let alone a valid one. The key point that seems to escape those of you with this squishy middle ground BS, is they should not be in this position at all, let alone having to have a point about being a woman. The only point that should matter is being, again as you so bravely stated, "women athletes."
Click to expand...
In playground terminology are they chicks with dicks or dudes with tits?
 
Hüsker Dü said:
I just see scared people reacting to things they seem to see through the lens they have been given. Not sure if many in here have said anything about trans rights only that they are cheating somehow? I pretty much agree with your opening paragraph, but who is to say that isn’t what has happened already? Do we know this all just based on what the potential athletes say or has there been testing of some kind? Just not a fan of fear based on biases.
Click to expand...
So Caitlyn Jenner is also transphobic?
 
Hüsker Dü said:
I just see scared people reacting to things they seem to see through the lens they have been given. Not sure if many in here have said anything about trans rights only that they are cheating somehow? I pretty much agree with your opening paragraph, but who is to say that isn’t what has happened already? Do we know this all just based on what the potential athletes say or has there been testing of some kind? Just not a fan of fear based on biases.
Click to expand...
All of the examples so far have been athletes who are born male, have XY chromosomes, and transition at some point later in life.

If they were using original birth certificate + DNA, they’d all be competing in a mens or boys division.
 
I have refrained from commenting, and some think I am a troll. That's fine. 99% of transgender kids are not very athletic. Having a transgender athlete be successful is a big step forward for awareness and normalization. It doesn't look like this swimmer had a big difference in sucess when male or female. Hormone suppressing drugs are very powerful, nauseating and exhausting and impact coordination and just ability to function so I understand the uproar if you don't know these things, but if you knew the backstory of these kids I think all of you as parent would just be really happy for this athlete. I have no personal knowledge about this swimmer but I am pretty sure that would be her story.
 
FutbolHeidiHo said:
I have refrained from commenting, and some think I am a troll. That's fine. 99% of transgender kids are not very athletic. Having a transgender athlete be successful is a big step forward for awareness and normalization. It doesn't look like this swimmer had a big difference in sucess when male or female. Hormone suppressing drugs are very powerful, nauseating and exhausting and impact coordination and just ability to function so I understand the uproar if you don't know these things, but if you knew the backstory of these kids I think all of you as parent would just be really happy for this athlete. I have no personal knowledge about this swimmer but I am pretty sure that would be her story.
Click to expand...
Understandable why you have refrained from commenting. Recommend return to refraining.
 
FutbolHeidiHo said:
I have refrained from commenting, and some think I am a troll. That's fine. 99% of transgender kids are not very athletic. Having a transgender athlete be successful is a big step forward for awareness and normalization. It doesn't look like this swimmer had a big difference in sucess when male or female. Hormone suppressing drugs are very powerful, nauseating and exhausting and impact coordination and just ability to function so I understand the uproar if you don't know these things, but if you knew the backstory of these kids I think all of you as parent would just be really happy for this athlete. I have no personal knowledge about this swimmer but I am pretty sure that would be her story.
Click to expand...
"I have no personal knowledge ... but I am pretty sure" could be the confession of many posters in this forum.
 
watfly said:
I'm going to continue to indulge you today just for fun. I'm pretty sure it's biology that sets the rules. The level of testosterone doesn't determine whether you're male or female. Your chromosomes determine that. This isn't about transgender rights, its about women's rights and exploiting and unfair advantage. Nor is it about discrimination because the individual is not prevented from competing, they just have to compete in the appropriate group. Not unlike why we have age or ability levels for many sports. You can play up but not play down because it creates an advantage in most cases.

When you transition post puberty you can't reverse that. You can't reverse you height, your arm length etc. I'm actually OK with prepuberty transitions competing in their identified gender, but not post puberty. You think you're carrying water for transgenders when in fact there is not universal support among transgenders and their families for MTF athletes competing against women.

Your lack of self awareness continues to infect your posts. You claim its just a race what's the big deal. That same attitude should apply to the trans swimmer. It must be a big deal if she is willing to take an unfair advantage to when a silly race. Do I think they transitioned to win NCAA swim races? No. Do I think they is exploiting that advantage for their benefit? 100%.
Click to expand...
science, biology - fake news. Dogma - now you are talking his love language..
 
dad4 said:
Suppose a low skill trans kid wants to try rec soccer. Born male, lives as female, no real soccer skills.

Who is harmed if they join a girls rec team?

The kind thing to do is to accommodate their request.
Click to expand...
The Truth is harmed...thus, encouraging more lies.

In your (and your fellow fence sitters) compromise of the Truth scenario...who determines and enforces skill levels and "no real soccer skills"? When player capacity numbers are reached, what happens to the next girl(s) who want to try girls soccer?

Mr. Thomas was ranked 400th+ amongst his collegiate male swimmer peers...so what ranking would you consider low skill? And again, who gets to establish what low skill is?

Accommodating a lie may very well be kind...but kind is an emotion...and emotions frequently act as blinders to facts and the Truth.

You either stand for the Truth or you do not...no fences to sit on with this one.
 
FutbolHeidiHo said:
I have refrained from commenting, and some think I am a troll. That's fine. 99% of transgender kids are not very athletic. Having a transgender athlete be successful is a big step forward for awareness and normalization. It doesn't look like this swimmer had a big difference in sucess when male or female. Hormone suppressing drugs are very powerful, nauseating and exhausting and impact coordination and just ability to function so I understand the uproar if you don't know these things, but if you knew the backstory of these kids I think all of you as parent would just be really happy for this athlete. I have no personal knowledge about this swimmer but I am pretty sure that would be her story.
Click to expand...
I agree with you and there are examples in modern day of trans athletes competing professionally with Women. However, this swimmer was a Male collegiate athlete thru his sophomore year then transitioned into her Junior year. So one year competing against Men and not finishing on a podium to the next year competing against Women and winning Medals.

If anything it begs a bigger investigation into who should be able to compete and why.
 
Kicker 2.0 said:
I agree with you and there are examples in modern day of trans athletes competing professionally with Women. However, this swimmer was a Male collegiate athlete thru his sophomore year then transitioned into her Junior year. So one year competing against Men and not finishing on a podium to the next year competing against Women and winning Medals.

If anything it begs a bigger investigation into who should be able to compete and why.
Click to expand...
...are they examples in modern day of men competing against women?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top