I don't think censorship is the right direction either and I think the more the left pushes on it the worse it's going to get. I know I'm fully capable to discern when Rogan is spewing BS and when he's not. I think the question I have, one I have no answer for, is how to reason about people believing everything someone like Alex Jones says. I know for a fact these people exist. I mean look at Qanon and all of that noise. I know conspiracy theorists have existed since the beginning of time, but in these days it feels much more accessible. Prior to the Internet it was just fringe beliefs. As far as opening it up for debate, I just don't see that happening -- I mean look at this thread.
That feeling you have (and I share your feelings towards extremists on the rights) is the same feeling I get from the left too. Like when the left tries to say the price increases are just due to corporations pushing profits instead of market forces setting prices. Or when they say the deficits can be waived away by taxing the 1 percent into oblivion. Or when they are shutting down schools but the bars and restaurants are packed to capacity and they are trying to put N95s on little kids. I have the same issue with those on the left that think they can waive away climate change with electric cars and renewables as I do with the climate deniers on the right.