Huh.Mask Mandate Reinstated in San Francisco—as Daily COVID Deaths Hit Zero
Mask orders have the effect of keeping the public in a perpetual state of emergency—and that might be the whole point.
Wednesday, August 4, 2021
https://fee.org/articles/mask-mandate-reinstated-in-san-francisco-as-daily-covid-deaths-hit-zero/
Why the Leviathan Loves Crisis
Many will argue that mask requirements are not overly invasive measures, and therefore are prudent as a mere precaution. After all, the case can be made that masks can offer protection against COVID-19 and help us wind down the pandemic sooner.
The problem is there’s a vast distance between recommending a policy for protection and mandating one. And as Washington, DC Mayor Muriel Bowser recently demonstrated, many public officials seem more fond of mask mandates than actually wearing masks themselves in social situations.
Additionally, mask orders have the effect of keeping the public in a state of emergency. As Stanford Professor of Medicine Dr. Jay Bhattacharya recently told FEE, there seems to be a reluctance on the part of many to admit the pandemic is all but over.
“We should be declaring a great and resounding success,” Bhattacharya told FEE’s Brad Polumbo. “The COVID emergency is over. We still need to take COVID seriously, and there are still vulnerable people here and abroad left to vaccinate. But we can start to treat it as one disease among many that afflict people rather than an all-consuming threat.”
This reluctance should come as little surprise. History shows that public officials struggle mightily to relinquish powers claimed during periods of emergency.
In his classic book Crisis and Leviathan, economist Robert Higgs noted that crises served as some of the biggest government power grabs in modern history. The New Deal was born out of the crisis of the Great Depression. The War on Terror and the Patriot Act were the rotten fruits of the 9-11 attacks. It was not accidental that these massive expansions of government followed crises.
“‘Emergencies’ have always been the pretext on which the safeguards of individual liberty have eroded,” the Nobel-Prize-winning economist Friedrich Hayek once observed. “And once they are suspended it is not difficult for anyone who has assumed emergency powers to see to it that the emergency will persist.”
Huh.
So, with a mask mandate and a 70% vaccination rate, SF has zero daily covid deaths.
Meanwhile, with no mask mandates and a 35% vaccination rate, Arkansas has about 20 daily covid deaths.
You'd almost think there is some kind of link there.
I don't think you'll be able to find a high vaccination rate city with a high IFR for current infections.Maybe. Let's see.
State of Arkansas IFR .0072
County of San Francisco IFR .0051
Three largest counties in Arkansas with a population of 891k+ has an IFR of .0097 compared to San Francisco's 874k+ at .0051.
Apples to Apples.....
Start the thread. I'll take care of the morbidity without the stories. Here is your first post. .00something. Takes all the emotion out of it.I was considering starting a new thread called something like "Covid Karma" just listing those critics of covid-prevention policies who subsequently became ill with the disease, but then I realized I didn't want to spend all day looking for morbid stories.
The immune system is designed to lower IFR as well. Only better when we look at low vax to high vax areas of comparable sizes.I don't think you'll be able to find a high vaccination rate city with a high IFR for current infections.
You see, the vaccine is designed to lower IFR.
Funny you picked Arkansas. They have 8 deaths, not 20 for comparable population size to SF. Less than half for a population that is half as vax'd as SF if you want to link anything.You won't be able to find a place with universal masks, 80% adult Pfizer/moderna vax rate, and over 5 daily covid deaths per million people. Go look. I'll wait.
Plenty of low vax rate, mask optional places with high deaths rates, though.
L.A. City Council President Nury Martinez and Councilman Mitch O’Farrell have introduced a motion instructing the city attorney to draft an ordinance requiring people in Los Angeles to provide proof of at least one vaccine dose in order to enter any indoor spaces “including but not limited to restaurants, bars, retail establishments, fitness centers, spas, and entertainment centers such as stadiums, concert venues, and movie theaters.”
There is no actual scientific or safety justification for such a demand. The motion itself notes that more than 70 percent of Los Angeles County residents over the age of 16 have gotten at least one vaccine dose. Hospitalizations and deaths in Los Angeles due to COVID-19 are indeed rising again, but they’re nowhere near where they were before vaccines became available. Hospitalizations won’t reach that spot again precisely because more than 70 percent of residents are at least partly vaccinated
“‘Emergencies’ have always been the pretext on which the safeguards of individual liberty have eroded,” the Nobel-Prize-winning economist Friedrich Hayek once observed. “And once they are suspended it is not difficult for anyone who has assumed emergency powers to see to it that the emergency will persist.”
The immune system is designed to lower IFR as well. Only better when we look at low vax to high vax areas of comparable sizes.
Funny you picked Arkansas. They have 8 deaths, not 20 for comparable population size to SF. Less than half for a population that is half as vax'd as SF if you want to link anything.
Good luck attempting to have a rational conversation with that one.Ok. 0 in SF compared to 8 daily deaths in Arkansas. Or 20 in Arkansas versus 0 in SF, depending on which population size is your default.
Sounds like the mask + vaccine plan has fewer covid deaths than the no mask + no vaccine plan.
Any luck finding a highly vaccinated city with high daily deaths?
comparable sizes.
Wow the fact you even thunk it shows what a horrible human being you are. We’re all eventually going to get it. At a minimum you’d think you’d limit your search to antivaxxers who subsequently came to acknowledge they made an error but guess that’s not you…no limiting principles.I was considering starting a new thread called something like "Covid Karma" just listing those critics of covid-prevention policies who subsequently became ill with the disease, but then I realized I didn't want to spend all day looking for morbid stories.
Wow the fact you even thunk it shows what a horrible human being you are. We’re all eventually going to get it. At a minimum you’d think you’d limit your search to antivaxxers who subsequently came to acknowledge they made an error but guess that’s not you…no limiting principles.
Or you could compare the no mask high vaccinated places like in the uk v masked high vaccinated places and maybe realize the masks aren’t doing that much esp ag the delta???Ok. 0 in SF compared to 8 daily deaths in Arkansas. Or 20 in Arkansas versus 0 in SF, depending on which population size is your default.
Sounds like the mask + vaccine plan has fewer covid deaths than the no mask + no vaccine plan.
Any luck finding a highly vaccinated city with high daily deaths?