Conflating Palestinians and Hamas as the same provides complete justification for every Palestinian death. That's too easy. I agree that polls do suggest that Gazans support Hamas. I have no idea why that is, but I also don't see that they have any alternative or that anyone is giving them an alternative, not least as Hamas would likely kill them! The PLA was an alternative, they proved themselves to be corrupt and inept, and remain so in the West Bank to this day.
Its hardly a surprise that Hamas imbeds itself in the civilian population. The question then becomes are you better than them, the same or more callous, given you have superiority in arms, numbers and technology. Hiding behind the refrain above doesn't excuse the death and destruction.
Israel is directly responsible for the Gazans. It is an occupied territory. They control everything that goes in and out and have done for decades. They are (internationally) responsible for every life in it. If they want out of that resonsibility then say the word and I'm sure it can be sorted out. They haven't and won't. Its a far stretch to call it a war. Are you acknowledging that innocent civilians are starving, is that OK? How many need to starve to death before the "I haven't killed every Hamas terrorist yet" isn't a good enough excuse?
For your Qs
- the settlers have been actively violent against Palestinians for a couple of decades. When they are tried, they are rarely convicted. There are 500K of them, and they are actively part of the current Israeli government.
- why don't Palestinians have equal rights in their own country? Who decided which ones could stay and which ones would be kicked out of their homes and shunted to the two current camps aka occupied territories?
- Israel hasn't kept to the peace deal either, see the first point above.
- typically that part not agreeing isn't asking for more death and destruction.
- I can't answer for Hamas, and wouldn't want to. I also wouldn't want to use them as my baseline level and would be horrified if my actions were so bad that I had to use their actions as "justification" - that would seem to make me no better.
- Apparently not. There have been rockets going from Gaza to Israel for years. There have been Israeli counter attacks etc going on for years. There was never an incursion and massacre like Oct 7th prior, but no, there was no ceasefire.
I was skeptical of the numbers too, but I've seen the qualification in a variety of media that the source for the numbers is generally accurate, so they are taken as verbatim. I have also not seen much denial from Israel and in fact have seen Israeli sources stating that they have killed 10-12K Hamas fighters and acknowledging the collateral deaths which are always a multiple. Below is from the BBC (Feb) and quotes a variety of official Israeli sources - you're welcome.
BBC Verify examines the evidence on combatant deaths, as concern grows about the scale of civilian killing.
www.bbc.com