I assume the shoot for the 25% part, maybe everything, but more on that.
Your kids grades, test score and soccer ability are their currency for getting in. Other things are too like legacy, donations, friends in high places, being the most interesting kid in the world and building houses for the poor in Africa. All play into admissions. But for the first ones only here is my odd reasoning.
Using two higher ranked schools as examples. A Player is smart and has 700 SAT Reading and Math. they are an A and B student with 3.6/4 GPA.
At UC Davis the 75th percentile SAT Reading/Math = 630/710 (they are good in math) ACT 30 (C9) https://www.sariweb.ucdavis.edu/commondataset/cds20152016.pdf
At Princeton the 25th percentile SAT Reading/Math = 690/700 ACT 32 https://registrar.princeton.edu/university_enrollment_sta/CDS2015-16.pdf
If the coaches want you for soccer - at both schools both SAT and Grades are good enough for both.
I think the one where the player is in the 25% makes them look better.
Same kind of pairing can be done on a Cal-State vs a UC. The 75% at a Cal-State is pretty close to a 25% at a UC. If the kid has a choice the one where they are in the 25% looks better.
Way too complicated for me.
Older son (2008 HS grad) had so-so grades, perhaps the best striker on his club team, but only a bench player and backup keeper on his HS team. He got community-college recruiting interest, but he chose to play on his U19 club team rather than CC. His club coach had played keeper for 5 years (including injury redshirt year) at a CSU DII school, so that worked into a successful on-campus tryout and coach's assistance with priority admission. Due to factors out of our control, he never enrolled there, and continued to play club until he aged out.
Second son (2010) had 3.2 GPA and pretty good test scores, and was selected for Cal South and Region IV ODP teams. After the ODP games in Florida, he had his pick of offers, and none of the coaches saw any problems with his grades or test scores.
Easy-peasy. No 25% or 75% needed.
Last edited: