Hüsker Dü
DA
China and Russia still are doing business there, embassy’s open.What are your thoughts on China supposedly wanting to come in and set up? Would like to here perspective thoughts on this…
China and Russia still are doing business there, embassy’s open.What are your thoughts on China supposedly wanting to come in and set up? Would like to here perspective thoughts on this…
There is no way we were going to put a "bow" on our results in Afghanistan, but we didn't need to trample the box before we mailed it.
Generally speaking, there are two camps within the veteran peer group. Those that spent a significant portion of their time in Afghanistan training Afghani troops. Many developed relationships and emotional ties. There there are those who's experience will be different. Their experience is watching Afghanis not show up at all during operations, turning and running during engagements, or turning their weapons on US or their afghani counterparts.I'm reading more and more posts like:
Mostly driven out by other invaders. A couple fell to civil war or domestic uprisings along language/ethnic lines.Where are they now?
Yes. And with good reason. I am referring to BRI or CPEC plans being laid out by China and Pakistan which can now include Afghanistan. And what else it will all mean.China and Russia still are doing business there, embassy’s open.
I guess I look at it differently. There was never going to be an orderly withdrawal, it's not the way country works. The agreements in place (and that remain in place until end of month) are going to avoid major bloodshed. The Taliban isn't generally going to interfere. They also aren't going to stop people from running onto the airfield. We aren't going to shoot anyone who runs onto the airfield and plane hops. We may scare them with helicopters, we may yell at them...but we aren't going to do much else. Hopefully not many more fall out of the wheel wells of C17s.There is no way we were going to put a "bow" on our results in Afghanistan, but we didn't need to trample the box before we mailed it.
They are also a tribal society. Loyalty lies to local leaders rather than a centralized form of government. That alone makes things shall we say rather difficult.You are comparing apples to oranges...The conquering isn't the hard part. It's being able to remain the conqueror that's the hard part. To understand the terrain in Afghanistan is to know it's the reason why afghans are nearly impossible to defeat. They retreat to the terrain that makes it impossible to get to them. The writing was on the wall the day we decided to build an all girls school in some god forsaken valley along the pak/afghan border. They chuckled when beauty salons opened in Kabul and Kandahar.
Western countries don't have the ganas to see these things through. We are not the soviet union, seeding entire valleys with mines that looked like toys. We are not built to fight long, ideological wars. The Afghanis literally have nothing else to do. They don't need progress, they don't need to evolve their society. We never lost an engagement in the field, yet we lost the war. Poetic to say the least and the only outcome possible.
No withdrawal was going to be perfect (withdrawing period is not a good look, but had to be done at some point), but I believe it could have been done in a more orderly fashion. You don't believe that? You don't think a complete cluster F could have been avoided? Maybe the difference between a minor cluster F and a complete cluster F is not all that different.I guess I look at it differently. There was never going to be an orderly withdrawal, it's not the way country works. The agreements in place (and that remain in place until end of month) are going to avoid major bloodshed. The Taliban isn't generally going to interfere. They also aren't going to stop people from running onto the airfield. We aren't going to shoot anyone who runs onto the airfield and plane hops. We may scare them with helicopters, we may yell at them...but we aren't going to do much else. Hopefully not many more fall out of the wheel wells of C17s.
All bets are off after end of the month. That's when will be given a glimpse behind the curtain.
The far right and most of the left's continued fascination with Trump is mind boggling to me. In the middle of the Afghanistan exit crisis, Maddow had an entire show devoted to Trump's failed attempt to influence the Georgia election.A biddy of mine sums up the current state of the US perfectly:
My current thoughts:
Trump is a stooge and completely unfit to run this country, hopefully he’ll go away. Stop waving flags with his name on it, it’s weird. I think most would agree with that.
Biden/Harris have been incompetent and are incapable of running this country. Everything they have done so far is complete . Biden can’t even think and talk, don’t tell me it’s a stutter, it’s his feeble mind, he’s incapable. Harris got less than 1% of her parties backing when she wanted to be president and it’s obvious why. Third in command is 131 year old Pelosi. Our administration is weak and embarrassing and the whole world knows it.
Meanwhile here’s the situation:
Border wide open during pandemic.
Inflation out of control.
Vax or mask, no vax and mask, no both and show vaccine card as proof.
CDC caught in multiple lies but we’re supposed to trust them.
Nobody wants to work, businesses struggling.
China and Russia taking control of everything.
Taliban back in control in Afghanistan.
Pipelines shut down, oil prices way up.
Religion frowned upon.
Violence rampant in big cities.
Speak against the far left, get labeled and/or silenced.
Etc, etc, etc.
The media and most Americans seem to be giving this administration a pass because “at least it’s not Trump”. I’m glad Trump is gone and hope he stays away but something has to change in this country before it’s too late. 330 million Americans and we had to choose between Trump and Biden/Harris?!?!?! That’s like picking which burning house to run into, the house is still going to burn down. The last 2 elections have crippled us.
I don’t know where good leadership will come from but we need to start praying that it comes soon. Most of us aren’t far left like the new Dems and most of us don’t back Trump….but we’re stuck in the middle and watching our country fall apart. I’m not going to stay quiet anymore and I think more people need to stand up for America before it’s too late.
Please pray for America.
#godblessamerica
Divert….deflect…..distract…..the MSM way!The far right and most of the left's continued fascination with Trump is mind boggling to me. In the middle of the Afghanistan exit crisis, Maddow had an entire show devoted to Trump's failed attempt to influence the Georgia election.
Border wide open during pandemic.
Inflation out of control.
No withdrawal was going to be perfect (withdrawing period is not a good look, but had to be done at some point), but I believe it could have been done in a more orderly fashion. You don't believe that? You don't think a complete cluster F could have been avoided? Maybe the difference between a minor cluster F and a complete cluster F is not all that different.
Afghanistan was generally a failure, but I take some solace in the fact that we were able to allow women to be educated for 20 years. I'm being a bit facetious, but may be next time we should arm the Afghan women instead of the male Afghan army.
The media can't even decide which side to land on. There has been such little reporting out of Afghanistan over the years that few understand the complexity and the nuance involved.Interesting read about how the press frames things. Compare and contrast.
The Media Can't Hide From Their Terrible Afghanistan Reporting
Biden's failure to fulfill corporate media's promises of his competence has made them look deeply foolish, as he displays the folly they predicted of Trump.thefederalist.com