100% agree. Pretty much what I do.
I don't say anything to the coach during the spring and summer tournaments. I like to give the coach space to experiment and understand the players he has and how they all fit together. I also want my child to work hard and step it up if playing time is lacking.
At ULittle, if by the middle of the fall season, there seems to be a disconnect between my child's quality of play/effort and the playing time, then I may ask the coach for some general feedback, so I can understand what's going on in the coach's head and see if I can understand the logic their operating under. But I don't explicitly complain and I don't make any specific demands. If it's UOlder, then that's between the player and coach, and I don't get involved at all.
By the end of the season if I'm still unhappy or I feel the coach is a poor fit for my child, then I simply leave at the end of the season. This has happened a couple of times, and both times the coaches were like, "I had no idea you were unhappy! I'm shocked that you're leaving!" Well they can be shocked all they want, but I and my child fulfilled the yearly commitment (finished state cup and everything) so I have a clean conscience. As NoGoal said, their actions speak louder than words. If they really felt my child was a valuable part of the team, then the playing-time would reflect so. Also they had a full-year with my child, if after a full-year my child's playing-time is still low, then the coach is doing a poor job developing him/her or my child can't keep up with the rest of the team. Either one is not a good reason to stay. The formula does change a bit as they get older, but under the age of 12 a kid should be on a team where they end the season with at least 70% playing time. If not, it's time to go elsewhere. No need to have a back and forth with a slick talking head coach whose just trying to maintain roster numbers.
Having said that, some parents hit the eject button way too soon...
The team has been practicing under him since Feb-March and we played a spring season - in total 10 matches to date. For some teams that's almost an entire league season. He hasn't moved anyone in and out of the starting lineup much at all, nor changed playing time allocation. That's our other concern. Every time she goes in the game she's with the other bench players so it makes it even tougher since they're all coming in cold and then only has a few mins before the half to get warm and make something happen - a tall task for a younger.
We started having concerns starting May and the feedback was to find a new team. We decided to stick it out instead of everyone's suggestion to cut bait but after another month and more games, it's become clear she's an afterthought.
Nonetheless, I still have high regard for this coach in terms of what he teaches the team and I strongly believe the team will be very successful but after 3 months knowing he hasn't paid much attention to her, I'm not going to risk spending a whole year riding the pine hoping he changes his mind. Even if it's justified, not getting playing time makes it exponentially harder to get better. Many don't believe it's justified.
We've already let the coach know that we'd like to move off the team. In response, we got several messages from well respected coaches within the club who would be readily recognized on this forum reassuring that she is a key player, she definitely belongs on this team and that she shouldn't have to move to play. They spoke to the coach on her behalf and encouraged us to meet with him again saying they would like us to stay where we are. One of these coaches recruited her to the club and is one of the top coaches in so cal.
We genuinely appreciated that, but I think given all the team dynamics etc... we really just want our DD to play for a coach and team that appreciate her for who she is - faults and all, where she can immediately make an impact, and who genuinely wants to help her develop. Not someone who thinks she doesn't deserve the playing time she's getting.
Perhaps she just needs a team where she can shine and build that confidence, not stuck behind other players shadows.
We do have much respect for the club and want to be loyal so we're waiting to hear back if they're willing to place her on the B team but we haven't heard back. so we're going to start reaching out to some coaches who have really been supportive of our DD in the past to see if they're interested. We've never played for them but they have always reached out to us and expressed that they would absolutely welcome her to the club. We always had a good relationship with them even when competing against.
I want to thank everyone for their input... this really has been such a difficult situation/decision and I genuinely appreciate all the advice - even wisecracks, I especially appreciate those who reached out via PM.
I hope if anything this thread helps others who may be feeling the same way process what's right for their kids, definitely a lot to think about!
My top three takeaways as of now...
1) I'm really glad we didn't go the ultimatum route, it's not who we are and I honestly don't think it wouldve helped anything. I don't recommend it.
2) no matter how I slice it, whether she's a rockstar and is being overlooked or just plain sucks, if she isn't getting playing time and opportunities to prove herself, she's on the wrong team. This is probably a little different for olders, but she's a younger and development is #1. She needs to find a team where she is an active contributor and the coach is invested in her.
3) things are never as bad as they seem. For a while it felt like the world was against us/her. We kept asking why, what's she doing wrong... we kept asking for feedback and she started training more and more. There was certainly no lack of effort on our part, even attending his other coaching sessions with olders to get more reps. In spite of this, there were parents on the team who would openly criticize her, yell at her at games, tell her to just pass the ball to the their kid the moment she touched the ball - no joke. Some parents would openly grumble in the few moments she was in the game that the coach wasn't playing to win. It took us a while to see through all that and realize a lot of those parents were just upset their kid was taken out. We learned to appreciate the parents who did encourage us and advocated on her behalf and the coaches who reached out to reassure us that she definitely belonged. Pay attention to these folks, but also trust your gut.