High School Forfeits

FWIW this is being messaged to the community as a grade eligibility issue, not an MLSN player.
Looks like you need to be 19 before June 15th for Junior and Senior teams and 17 before Aug 31st for Freshman and Sophmore teams. But there's lots of waivers.

Either way this would translate into a player being over 3-4 years older than the youngest player per grade if someone was cheating
 
Looks like you need to be 19 before June 15th for Junior and Senior teams and 17 before Aug 31st for Freshman and Sophmore teams. But there's lots of waivers.

Either way this would translate into a player being over 3-4 years older than the youngest player per grade if someone was cheating
The eligibility issue was related to grades not age.

 
Eric reports Chatsworth forfeits due to ineligible player (outside league). Irvine University moves onto the regional final by default.
 
My son's school has some MLSN players who just didn't play HS soccer. I assume that's the case for most players in that situation.

On a related note, I don't see why teams below Varsity (and especially Frosh teams) don't just forfeit all their games up-front, play the games anyway, and let their kids practice/play externally also. The season results don't matter for anything (no playoffs, and Frosh game results aren't even tracked anywhere in my son's school case); there's no good reason to prevent those kids from playing externally during the HS season, if the official results of the games don't matter for anything. It's only Varsity where the results matter at all, for playoffs and school rankings, and such.
Because it would be unethical...something that never stopped you, of course. Dusting off your old "pre-forfeit" scam. You'll always be con artist, but at least now everyone knows.
 
My son's school has some MLSN players who just didn't play HS soccer. I assume that's the case for most players in that situation.

On a related note, I don't see why teams below Varsity (and especially Frosh teams) don't just forfeit all their games up-front, play the games anyway, and let their kids practice/play externally also. The season results don't matter for anything (no playoffs, and Frosh game results aren't even tracked anywhere in my son's school case); there's no good reason to prevent those kids from playing externally during the HS season, if the official results of the games don't matter for anything. It's only Varsity where the results matter at all, for playoffs and school rankings, and such.
If a game is forfeited in advance, there might be some difficulty getting referees for the game.
 
If a game is forfeited in advance, there might be some difficulty getting referees for the game.
That's a reasonable point; there might be some logistical complications. My thought was just that it seems silly in some cases to "lock out" players from playing externally during the whole season, particularly in cases where they are playing for a team where the results have no meaning or consequence (and aren't even recorded, in some cases), and where the actual practice/game schedule is substantially shorter than the whole season.

As an example, my son's HS Frosh team played 5 games (total), ended their practices and season about a month before the last day of competition (which is even before playoffs), and basically had a month and a half of nothing, when the club team was still on HS season break and not practicing. Meanwhile a same-age club team, with non-HS players, was still participating in a winter league, practicing, and playing games. While I think there was value in the HS team experience, I also think it would benefit the kids more if they could not worry about playing club games also during the season, with the up-front understanding that since the HS team results are immaterial, forfeiting on paper (maybe after the game is played) would be totally fine. That would seem to allow the best opportunities for the kids, at least.
 
I can tell you exactly why you cant play scheduled games (more than one in a row aka "friendlies"). When theres no repercussions for players actions, what are you going to do? Double kick them out? There has to be something that players want in the future that keeps current behavior in check.


I always liked this scene. Its something every guy can relate to.
 
High School season is getting underway and it has been an interesting first 2 weeks:

The local high school soccer program has historically been run by a club director. Parent's were not a huge fan of his style, but he knows soccer and got the team into the playoffs the last 4 years (with 1 promotion).

This year, he decided to sit out a season so the school brought in a new varsity coach. The new coach's experience stems exclusively from 7v7 AYSO volunteer coaching and AYSO all-stars with no coaching license. Assistant coaches cut from the same mold. First day of tryouts, he announced that all the club players have been "institutionalized" by the pay to play system and that they'd need to play differently.

Rosters have been sorted and the final tally is in:

Varsity - 100% club players

JV - 85% club players with 3 rec players

warms ups have consisted of long, static stretching before launching into full circuit sprints. Rondo's have a mandatory 2 touch minimum with 6 players outside a 12 yard circle and 1 player in the middle. Finishing drills have all been 10 yards outside the penalty box and ball inflation has held steady at a squishy 7psi.

First games begin this week and a number of players still have club games through the Thanksgiving holiday (including showcases in December), but he wants to teach the players about honoring commitments and expects them to skip the end of club.

Club certainly has it’s drawbacks, but nothing like this. I can't wait to see what the rest of the season brings!
 
First games begin this week and a number of players still have club games through the Thanksgiving holiday (including showcases in December), but he wants to teach the players about honoring commitments and expects them to skip the end of club.
I must admit I find it curious why some schools (including my son's) elect to play a game this week. First of all, with tryouts last week, they'll have had what amounts to two actual practices. Secondly, as you point out, it puts many Club players in a (needless) bind, as all of next week is a holiday, so the next opportunity for a HS match is December. Seems better for all involved to just take a pass on that first game window.
 
I must admit I find it curious why some schools (including my son's) elect to play a game this week. First of all, with tryouts last week, they'll have had what amounts to two actual practices. Secondly, as you point out, it puts many Club players in a (needless) bind, as all of next week is a holiday, so the next opportunity for a HS match is December. Seems better for all involved to just take a pass on that first game window.
Half our team played HS games last Friday and we then lost on Saturday, playing by far the worst we’d done all season.
 
Half our team played HS games last Friday and we then lost on Saturday, playing by far the worst we’d done all season.
I'm confused--I thought that was not allowed by CIF rules? I.e., if they played in a HS game Friday, they need to sit out of Club games--or run the risk of getting the HS disqualified like those that triggered this thread last year?

(I also presume you are not in San Diego, as the SDUSD season starts tomorrow.)
 
I'm confused--I thought that was not allowed by CIF rules? I.e., if they played in a HS game Friday, they need to sit out of Club games--or run the risk of getting the HS disqualified like those that triggered this thread last year?

(I also presume you are not in San Diego, as the SDUSD season starts tomorrow.)
This is accurate: any player who played a CIF-listed HS game (ie: an official "interscholastic competition") on Friday started their HS "season of sport" on Friday, and would become an ineligible player for the remainder of the HS season if they subsequently played a club game on Saturday.

As noted in this thread, though, that usually doesn't really come until play until/unless playoffs, and often the HS coaches cannot check status either. I've also noticed that many parents also do not know the rules accurately (I had a higher-up parent in our club tell our club admin the wrong information on this explicitly, and I needed to look up to confirm I was correct, and then make sure I informed the admin and our parents of the correct info). I suspect there are a huge number of kids who do this (at the start of seasons), and it only really comes out at playoff time which teams were still eligible for such after some investigation.
 
High School season is getting underway and it has been an interesting first 2 weeks:

The local high school soccer program has historically been run by a club director. Parent's were not a huge fan of his style, but he knows soccer and got the team into the playoffs the last 4 years (with 1 promotion).

This year, he decided to sit out a season so the school brought in a new varsity coach. The new coach's experience stems exclusively from 7v7 AYSO volunteer coaching and AYSO all-stars with no coaching license. Assistant coaches cut from the same mold. First day of tryouts, he announced that all the club players have been "institutionalized" by the pay to play system and that they'd need to play differently.

Rosters have been sorted and the final tally is in:

Varsity - 100% club players

JV - 85% club players with 3 rec players

warms ups have consisted of long, static stretching before launching into full circuit sprints. Rondo's have a mandatory 2 touch minimum with 6 players outside a 12 yard circle and 1 player in the middle. Finishing drills have all been 10 yards outside the penalty box and ball inflation has held steady at a squishy 7psi.

First games begin this week and a number of players still have club games through the Thanksgiving holiday (including showcases in December), but he wants to teach the players about honoring commitments and expects them to skip the end of club.

Club certainly has it’s drawbacks, but nothing like this. I can't wait to see what the rest of the season brings!
Oof, sounds painful. Nothing like having AYSO coaches thinking they can jump from 7v7 kiddie soccer to HS with a bunch of club players. The good news is that club players at that age will be able to filter any non-sensical coaching and just play the way that they're used to in games.
 
Oof, sounds painful. Nothing like having AYSO coaches thinking they can jump from 7v7 kiddie soccer to HS with a bunch of club players. The good news is that club players at that age will be able to filter any non-sensical coaching and just play the way that they're used to in games.
Backline and the build out is a problem if the coach doesn’t know what to do there. Hopefully the coach at least played college. Otherwise you need a gk who is very tactically advanced and at least one cb the same AND they are on the same page in organizing the defensive line and height of the block. When the gk and cb aren’t on the same page and the coach isn’t strong enough to control them that’s bad…very bad…worst of all possible worlds even if both are great players individually.
 
I'm confused--I thought that was not allowed by CIF rules? I.e., if they played in a HS game Friday, they need to sit out of Club games--or run the risk of getting the HS disqualified like those that triggered this thread last year?

(I also presume you are not in San Diego, as the SDUSD season starts tomorrow.)

They were just scrimmages. Not sanctioned games.
 
They were just scrimmages. Not sanctioned games.
Scrimmages still might count. Depends on how it was done. If score kept and refs used or if advertised to students as "the first game" that’s still a problem because it might rise to the level of an “inter scholastic contest”…players might be ineligible even if coaches called it a scrimmage if they then played a club games. There are rules also surrounding how many and when they can take place and who may participate and how long they can last. It’s why most schools tend to avoid them…it’s an easy trap.
 
Last edited:
Scrimmages still might count. Depends on how it was done. If score kept and refs used or if advertised to students as "the first game" that’s still a problem because it might rise to the level of an “inter scholastic contest”…players might be ineligible even if coaches called it a scrimmage if they then played a club games. There are rules also surrounding how many and when they can take place and who may participate and how long they can last. It’s why most schools tend to avoid them…it’s an easy trap.
Scrimmages don't count. Look up the game on https://cifss.org/schedules-and-scores. If it's not listed then it's a scrimmage.
 
Do you know people who school choice to a particular high school so they can get on a good soccer team? Or is soccer still considered a niche sport that gets no credibility and no one cares about in high school? I’m waiting on the day my son wakes up and realizes the sport he plays 15 hours a week and consumes so much of his life is a meaningless endeavor. He is better off doing after school Robotics. Do you let them quit on their own or do you step in and say enough soccer, I have signed you up for robotics. It’s an especially difficult decision if the kid is still good but not 99.99 percentile good. Just like soccer, Robotics has a window too and it has its own 10000 hr learning curve, you missed it it’s hard to catch up.
 
Do you know people who school choice to a particular high school so they can get on a good soccer team? Or is soccer still considered a niche sport that gets no credibility and no one cares about in high school? I’m waiting on the day my son wakes up and realizes the sport he plays 15 hours a week and consumes so much of his life is a meaningless endeavor. He is better off doing after school Robotics. Do you let them quit on their own or do you step in and say enough soccer, I have signed you up for robotics. It’s an especially difficult decision if the kid is still good but not 99.99 percentile good. Just like soccer, Robotics has a window too and it has its own 10000 hr learning curve, you missed it it’s hard to catch up.
Yes, very common here in San Diego
 
Scrimmages don't count. Look up the game on https://cifss.org/schedules-and-scores. If it's not listed then it's a scrimmage.
Calling a game a "scrimmage" doesn't automatically exempt it if it violates the strict legal definition of a scrimmage under CIF rules. Under CIF-SS Bylaw 2704, an interscholastic scrimmage is strictly defined as a training session where no score is kept, free substitutions are allowed, and spectators are not urged to attend. The moment officials keep an official score or the school markets and conducts it like a standard match, it ceases to be a scrimmage and legally converts into a non-league interscholastic contest. Under CIF State Bylaw 600 and CIF-SS Bylaw 504 / 2708, a player’s "season of sport" officially begins the second they participate in their first “interscholastic contest”, not “game” or “match”. Once that season of sport is triggered, competing in any outside club match makes the player immediately ineligible under Bylaw 600—resulting in a minimum two-game suspension per outside match played and forcing the high school to forfeit any games that player participated in afterward. Ultimately, CIF rules judge an event by how it is actually conducted on the field and not by what label the coaches put on it. It’s why schools tend to avoid them…very easy to get tripped up under the bylaws.
 
Last edited:
Do you know people who school choice to a particular high school so they can get on a good soccer team? Or is soccer still considered a niche sport that gets no credibility and no one cares about in high school? I’m waiting on the day my son wakes up and realizes the sport he plays 15 hours a week and consumes so much of his life is a meaningless endeavor. He is better off doing after school Robotics. Do you let them quit on their own or do you step in and say enough soccer, I have signed you up for robotics. It’s an especially difficult decision if the kid is still good but not 99.99 percentile good. Just like soccer, Robotics has a window too and it has its own 10000 hr learning curve, you missed it it’s hard to catch up.
Oh yeah. We’ve known some top players for example who angle to get into top flight schools like Crossroads or Cathedral or even Moorpark. Also the other way. A dad at the office approached me yesterday because his kid is entering middle school next year, is still AYSO all stars and just found out his kid’s (whose sole sport is soccer) school is Granada Hills which means he ain’t getting on that team even just with SoCal League club. Guy was shocked…kids plan was always to play for his high school…had no idea how competitive high school was (this is always why second siblings have an edge up on older siblings when it comes to college athletics…the knowledge gap). For my kid we chose a smaller private than my Alma matter where he could start jv as a freshman and play as a varsity as a sophomore (made all cif last year).

As to the parenting aspect my advice is you gotta let the kid make his own decision and only thing you can do is funnel them info. They gotta have at least two extracurricular anyway so in high school they have to do something other than sports unless they are going d1 recruitment (and that’s just giving them info…if a boy hey you aren’t at an academy or one of the very top mls hg or ecnl teams in the country). Robotics isn’t much better btw. The colleges don’t care if you are just robotics. To get noticed you’d need to actually win competitions or be the president or get a write up somewhere. There are crazy parents at some of the privates who get their kids engineering tutors at the colleges who did robotics to help them win and the private hire top notch coaches that have in fact won. Heck, to get into a top writing program (lots of wanna be ivies too) the gold standard is Iowa young writers summer and they take about 20kids from SoCal each summer and about 20 students applied last year at Harvard westlake alone.
 
Back
Top