I am not sure #1 is true anymore. Maybe if you want to train in a "pod," don't care if the DOC knows your name, and are fully committed to never playing HS soccer. I am sure Surf will continue to grab some great players, but those players need to have a specific goal and play the style the DOC likes.
If you are going to change DMCV you are going to have to make some changes that will make some people angry. Not much different than when the DOC came in recently at Surf.
AW is a great coach and he does a good job of developing young kids, but I do think you are overstating his recruiting abilities.
I am pulling for DMCV. After what I saw at Surf I am certain they need a few setbacks to really evaluate who they are as an organization.