State Cup

samsung1 said:
No call or warning.
Click to expand...

I can understand no call if none of the referee saw the foul, but if they saw it and didn't call it then there was a problem with the referee crew. Players will usually take care of these types of non-calls on their own by retaliating later in the game with a cleat down the calf/Achilles or elbow to the jaw. High school age girls are vicious. These types of game critical fouls can change the whole tempo of the game and change a smooth clean game into an out of control brawl. Referee crews must be paying attention and get these calls correct.

I have no problem with showing the pictures of the dirty play. I have seen many photos and videos on this site showing both clean and nasty fouls. If that was my DD in the red jersey, I would be chewing her out for the dirty play.
 
i walked around quite a bit and watched tidbits of boys and girls up in the far off land of Lancaster.

I saw stuff like this on almost every field, boys and girls.


Also saw way more yellow cards to coaches than I have in the last ~6 years.
 
Monkey said:
What is the point of posting pictures of a minor when emotions appear to have gotten the best of her?

Are you hoping to bring it to her attention, her parents or the coach's attention, CalSouth or the refs?

I don't even know if it is legal to post something like this about a minor.
Click to expand...

I'm with you on this, I think its pathetic that an adult would post pictures, or support posting pictures, of a minor in an attempt to publicly shame a child. If you have a problem with it take it to the appropriate association. Yeah, they might not do something about it but, that doesn't make it OK to dish out internet vigilante justice on a minor.

Was it a foul deserving of a card, absolutely. However, we don't know the context. I've seen normally mellow kids lose their temper and do something stupid on the pitch after getting continually hacked during the game. We've all done things we regret and how would we like it to be posted on a public forum? We don't earn the designation "Deputy of Fair Play" just because we're a member on this forum.

If you can't get over the kids rough play, then act like an adult and have the balls to show those pictures directly to the parent.
 
Sheriff Joe said:
Bullshit, 4 years of pretty high level club soccer and I have seen this once or twice, almost every game?
Come on.
Click to expand...
It's state cup; so not high level soccer. IMO, the lower levels are far more physical than the higher levels which are trying to play actual soccer
 
Sheriff Joe said:
Bullshit, 4 years of pretty high level club soccer and I have seen this once or twice, almost every game?
Come on.
Click to expand...

Sorry, I wasn't clear. I didn't see this particular mugging in every game, I saw out-of-order physical play all over the place, different fields at different times, but never constrained to just one gender or club, or one pool.
 
Maybe it wasn't an adult that took and posted the picture?
Maybe the kid doing the cattle roping was trying to get on Instagram to get a bunch of new followers?
#Worldstar!!!!!
 
OrangeCountyDad said:
Sorry, I wasn't clear. I didn't see this particular mugging in every game, I saw out-of-order physical play all over the place, different fields at different times, but never constrained to just one gender or club, or one pool.
Click to expand...
Got it, my daughter was on the receiving end of a shitty trip after she went around a defender after scoring 2 goals against the same defender earlier in the game and broke her arm.
I know it happens, but 6 weeks in a cast sure sucks.
Peace.
 
toucan said:
Samsung just likes shaming kids. Having a camera gives him the opportunity. Yes, it looks like the girl is guilty of committing a hard and unnecessary foul. But she is a kid. She was presumably called for a foul, and that should be the end of it. Keep these things on the field. Samsung is a grown-up. Samsung wants to stigmatize a girl, and that should never be allowed. A kid committing a foul should told, taught and forgiven. A grown-up who puts it online for the purpose of forever shaming the kid is a baby and a jackass. He (or she) is the real thug.
Click to expand...
She is not a “kid” she is a teenager that knows exactly what she is doing!.
 
Sheriff Joe said:
Got it, my daughter was on the receiving end of a shitty trip after she went around a defender after scoring 2 goals against the same defender earlier in the game and broke her arm.
I know it happens, but 6 weeks in a cast sure sucks.
Peace.
Click to expand...
Exact thing happened to my DD and cast for 6 weeks.
 
Lurker said:
She is not a “kid” she is a teenager that knows exactly what she is doing!.
Click to expand...

Unfortunately, that is the same logic some unsavory adults use for other misdeeds. I get it, your emotional because your daughter broke her arm, I'd be pissed too; however, a minor is a minor. It's not OK for an adult to post a picture of a minor for purposes of shaming one in public regardless of the rationalization.
 
Sheriff Joe said:
Bullshit, 4 years of pretty high level club soccer and I have seen this once or twice, almost every game?
Come on.
Click to expand...

I was in Lancaster, I saw the paramedics twice taking a couple of kids to the hospital. A few teams had 3 red cards and several had 2 red cards over the weekend games. One kid pulled back the arm of another kid until he took him down to the ground. Maybe it was the wind but it was very physical for the 2003 boys age group in Lancaster last weekend.
 
Soccer's physical.
Sports are emotional.
Players play to win.
Some teams play aggressive.
Injuries are part of the game.

People need to stop crying wolf because we all know exactly what we signed our kids up for.

The original poster's a complete clown for posting these pictures that explain absolutely nothing more then his daughter got throttled and he wasn't happy about it.
 
Chalklines said:
Soccer's physical.
Sports are emotional.
Players play to win.
Some teams play aggressive.
Injuries are part of the game.

People need to stop crying wolf because we all know exactly what we signed our kids up for.

The original poster's a complete clown for posting these pictures that explain absolutely nothing more then his daughter got throttled and he wasn't happy about it.
Click to expand...

Agree. The OP's images are completely without a context and are three slices of continuing play. We know nothing of preceding events, or where the ball is.

Maybe OP's kid is the one throttling and not the other way around.... Or is it even OP's kid in the image? Just saying...
 
watfly said:
Unfortunately, that is the same logic some unsavory adults use for other misdeeds. I get it, your emotional because your daughter broke her arm, I'd be pissed too; however, a minor is a minor. It's not OK for an adult to post a picture of a minor for purposes of shaming one in public regardless of the rationalization.
Click to expand...

I don't agree with this at all. The photos appear to identify a malicious physical attack from behind that was intended to hurt another child, and by someone who is old enough to know better. It also seems very unlikely this was the perpetrator’s first or even second incident because people don’t typically snap perfectly framed action photos of attacks away from the action unless they expect it to happen.

If a player is a menace who risks intentionally hurting other children, I see nothing wrong in letting others should know about it. If shaming this kid and her parents deters future similar behavior, the person who posted the photos should get a medal. And perhaps this kid will learn that actions have consequences before she does something even more stupid that gets posted on the internet or lands her in jail.

Who are we trying to protect? Kids who hurt other children? Or their victims?
 
watfly said:
Unfortunately, that is the same logic some unsavory adults use for other misdeeds. I get it, your emotional because your daughter broke her arm, I'd be pissed too; however, a minor is a minor. It's not OK for an adult to post a picture of a minor for purposes of shaming one in public regardless of the rationalization.
Click to expand...
I wasn’t speaking about the posting of a picture but I was speaking to excusing the teenager because she was a “Kid”.
 
Lurker said:
I wasn’t speaking about the posting of a picture but I was speaking to excusing the teenager because she was a “Kid”.
Click to expand...
My sincere apologies to you.

My comment still stands for the others here that thinks its OK because they are teenagers. I guess I wasn't aware that soccer fouling teenage girls were such a threat to humanity.
 
InTheValley said:
I don't agree with this at all. The photos appear to identify a malicious physical attack from behind that was intended to hurt another child, and by someone who is old enough to know better. It also seems very unlikely this was the perpetrator’s first or even second incident because people don’t typically snap perfectly framed action photos of attacks away from the action unless they expect it to happen.

If a player is a menace who risks intentionally hurting other children, I see nothing wrong in letting others should know about it. If shaming this kid and her parents deters future similar behavior, the person who posted the photos should get a medal. And perhaps this kid will learn that actions have consequences before she does something even more stupid that gets posted on the internet or lands her in jail.

Who are we trying to protect? Kids who hurt other children? Or their victims?
Click to expand...

Pathetic.......most pathetic post I've seen in long time. "malicious physical attack" .. Please

It's just a game. It ends once the ref blows the whistle.

Nothings criminal here except the fact you drive on the same roads as I do.
 
Chalklines said:
Pathetic.......most pathetic post I've seen in long time. "malicious physical attack" .. Please

It's just a game. It ends once the ref blows the whistle.

Nothings criminal here except the fact you drive on the same roads as I do.
Click to expand...

Nice. A graduate of the Trump school of debate, replete with ad hominem attacks. Because you want to go down that road, I’m not surprised that you must resort to personal attacks instead of substantive discussion - or by your opinion - since you seem to fit the Texas high school football coach stereotype perfectly. Given your inability to grasp fundamental concepts in grammar, punctuation and spelling, I hope they didn’t let you teach while you were there.

Technically, the child’s behavior probably was a criminal battery if, as it appears, it occurred off the ball and not in self-defense. I’m glad law enforcement has better things to do, however, especially because public shaming and hopefully a red card are likely to be sufficient. I would have thought a tough guy like you would recognize that a few pictures like these on the internet aren’t going to ruin anyone’s life. But maybe you are one of those snowflake parents raising children to be so emotionally soft that they can’t handle it? Like you said, it’s just a game. So why are so agitated?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top