As mentioned in other threads, the Fall showcase in Phoenix was awesome. We too had over 100 coaches on the sideline, mostly D1 EVEN with College Cup going on. Most coaches weren’t on the list. They showed up. At this point both leagues are running parallel to each other which in my opinion is asinine. To add to that point the silly rule regarding College I.D. Camps for GDA. DA’s focus being YNT pool and ECNL college. NorCal has been ECNL dominate with the exception of Quakes . Every other top club is ECNL in NorCal. College coaches and NT staff are at both showcase events. I tend to like the regional showcases that ECNL offers.
@Dabizness I don’t think much has changed with regards to recruiting except for the minor NCAA changes. Players are being heavily recruited regardless of league. A coach told my DD once if he doesn’t pick the best he doesn’t get to eat. They aren’t looking at the league at all. They are looking for the best players for their perspective programs so they can keep their jobs.
As for the competition level, both leagues have their top teams and teams at the bottom. The problem is the dilution overall. Southwest ECNL is much more challenging this season as opposed to last year. So, I do see a shift back to ECNL at least for our age group. I also believe that if these two leagues were combined the top ECNL teams wouldn’t be in the middle of the pack of GDA. We have already seen what happens at crossover events (e.g. silverlakes).
With regards to the showcases, which is the biggest selling point for me, at any given age level ECNL will have one more event than GDA. At U16 for example, the players are required to play in a minimum of 3 college showcases, and they typically will play at the National event in June as long as they don’t finish in the bottom 2 of their conference. So, for U16, those girls have 4 college showcases as compared to the 2 in GDA.
Pick the coach, and best situation for your player. If your player is NT material they will find her regardless of league. If your player is headed to college they will find her at a showcase

.