Easy. I have been around the youth game for many years, at many clubs, and have not noticed this "sleaze" to which you refer. I have noticed a lot of disgruntled parents, however...and I have been one. The most extreme among them blame criminal behavior for keeping their kid on the bench, which is total b.s. I just figured when 2 or 3 people are chattering on this forum about payoffs to coaches and sleazy youth soccer business, without any examples or willingness to be specific, they sound like they are bitter about something. They wouldn't be bitter if their kid was playing. Therefore, I naturally assume that they are ascribing their kid's not playing to some mysterious graft or other illicit behavior by coaches and parents. It's probably not that; it's that the kid isn't good enough.
So you've never seen a kid dramatically increase playing time by paying for exorbitant privates with the head coach? You've never heard a DOC say that their club is all about development, when in fact they're serving up win-at-all costs soccer and doing everything they can to recruit players away from rival teams? You've never seen a coach put short term success over the long term development of a player? You've never seen a coach take a ton of money for privates from a kid who obviously will never reach his/her goals? You've never heard a DOC talk about college recruitment to rec level players? You've never seen a club where finances are completely mismanaged? You've never seen dynamic young coaches farting around with u-little C teams while the mailing-it-in texters handle the big-roster high school A teams? You've never heard of a coach lying about their licence? You've never heard of age violations? You've never seen DOCs covering up for alcoholic or abusive coaches? You've never seen coaches stack their rosters to increase their salaries? You've never noticed a coach belatedly realizing he can't play on Yom Kippur just after his star player is injured (admittedly, that probably only happens in CSL)? You've never noticed the most winning coach at a club happens to coach the club president's DD?
You've really never seen adults in youth soccer put their own personal interests above those of the youths they are supposed to be teaching?!
All of that stuff is completely standard, that's not getting into the serious stuff of embezzlement and sexual assault. Those happen less frequently, but I can't believe you haven't heard of specific instances of that in all your years.
My kid is only an 06, so I haven't been around that long, but I've seen or heard of all of that stuff (including the serious stuff). That doesn't even include the stuff I've read about here. Perhaps all that crap falls within your personal set of ethics, but I know I wouldn't do those things myself.
Listen, don't get me wrong. I love club soccer. Bitterness is the last thing I feel about club soccer. It's been a fantastic experience for my family, full of drama, life lessons, and yes, soccer development. But most (notably, not all) of my sons coaches or clubs engaged in some form of that sleaze, and we had to discuss it all as family at the time (and we didn't just "tell him to get better").
...they sound like they are bitter about something. They wouldn't be bitter if their kid was playing. Therefore, I naturally assume...
I absolutely agree that there are a lot of crazy parents. The parents who don't have an inflated sense of their kids' skills are few and far between. Absolutely. But where you go off track is to assume that the only possible reason to be "bitter" is if your kid isn't playing. That doesn't follow. There are many improvements to be made. In fact, I think the kids who are the absolute best are the ones who are most poorly served by the sleaze and therefore have the most right to complain -- there are plenty of roster spots available for mediocre players.
Twice on this thread you've slapped people with this argument. Fishme1 pretty definitely established that his kids play at the highest level. Personally, I see no reason to get into my own kid, except to say I'm totally comfortable with his level. Whether he benches on a Flight 3 C team or starts on a CSL-winning Gold team doesn't affect my ability to observe that the structure of club soccer in the US tolerates and even incentivizes some pretty crappy behaviour by those in positions of authority.