Bad look for the GA

GA has been neck and neck in RL territory since is creation. It's the hard truth that the GA propagandists have been dodging and arguing about on here for years. TopHat has been the go to anecdotal argument the entire time.

Like it was stated before, the TopHat performance during the upcoming season in ECNL will show everybody where the top GA teams compare, and therefore where all the mid and low tier GA teams would be as well.

Spoiler alert. ECRL = GA in level of play and player talent. It's also going to expose the Soccer Ranking Apps failure to accurately rank cross league comparisons.
I disagree. GA’s top clubs are ECNL caliber. The rest, yeah they are closer to RL level. I think tophat will be a mid level ECNL club the first year or two.Their u15 team is very average on a national scale in the GA. They will start pulling better talent once they are in though.
 
It's also going to expose the Soccer Ranking Apps failure to accurately rank cross league comparisons.
I'm not sure that's a fair take. If you look at all of the clubs that have already made the move in either direction in past seasons, there hasn't been a big shift in how those clubs are perceived the season afterwards with SR. Look at the Nationals, the Ukies, Select, or any of the other GA clubs that hopped over. They were quite strong in GA, and when moved over to ECNL they saw tougher competition - but their overall club rank didn't move much at all. Or you could look at a club like Midwest United, who left ECNL as a relatively weaker club, and our now seeing more success in GA - but the club rank is still nowhere near the top (while it is near the top of GA). Teams/clubs are never going to stay exactly the same, as their movement is certainly going to affect recruiting/retention in various ways, but it's hard to see how their performance over time is being misinterpreted. Are you thinking that the actual performance gap should be represented larger, or it's being represented overly large?

There is no concept of "league" as the teams continue to update their ratings by playing other teams with their own ratings. The only thing this mathematical criticism could be aimed at, is if the cross-play is too limited to provide enough data to be statistically relevant. With them looking at this and analyzing it for many years, SR doesn't believe so. What I see they have done, is show more detailed reasoning when teams do not have enough history to have a relevant ranking. The app shows that it is "an isolated group of teams" until they get enough games against enough different teams to meet the threshold. If the team shows a rating/ranking - their game history is statistically relevant enough to show. None of this implies perfection, and previous performance for a team certainly doesn't guarantee future performance. But historically - it generally does. It being "wrong" about a game/team/club, is rare, and every game helps it chase whatever is "correct" up through the game date.
 
I disagree. GA’s top clubs are ECNL caliber. The rest, yeah they are closer to RL level. I think tophat will be a mid level ECNL club the first year or two.Their u15 team is very average on a national scale in the GA. They will start pulling better talent once they are in though.
What exactly does "ECNL caliber" mean? Not every girls ECNL team is in the top 30 nationally. Yes, girls ECNL is top heavy with highly ranked teams. But, they also have their fair share of bottom feeders. Also it depends on which ECNL league you're talking about. Some are all quality, some aren't.

What ECNL has done is pick off some of GAs top clubs. If GA doesnt answer this spring converting top ECNL clubs to GA the writing is on the wall for GA. Its just a matter of time for things to play out.
 
One of TopHat's leaders is(was) the vice president of the executive board of GA, 2nd in command. He was just removed from GA's website, even though he still shows up on google cache. He had to know everything that GA was planning to thrive and grow - that was his job - yet TopHat instead chose to get out of dodge.
 
What exactly does "ECNL caliber" mean? Not every girls ECNL team is in the top 30 nationally. Yes, girls ECNL is top heavy with highly ranked teams. But, they also have their fair share of bottom feeders. Also it depends on which ECNL league you're talking about. Some are all quality, some aren't.

What ECNL has done is pick off some of GAs top clubs. If GA doesnt answer this spring converting top ECNL clubs to GA the writing is on the wall for GA. Its just a matter of time for things to play out.
Yes, I am comparing the top 30ish ECNL teams (specifically the ECNL southwest conference) to the GA’s top. Of course they have bottom feeders but from what I’ve seen, the best GA teams are middle of the pack depending on conference. At this point though who cares. How does the GA respond? There are only a handful of strong GA clubs left. Do anymore leave? Do only clubs with MLS next on the boys side stay? If any one of City, Jags, NEFC, Indy Premier leave the GA is done imo. Their relevance as a top D1 pathway is hanging on by a thread. What is the ECNL’s goal? Do they want the GA gone? Is there any hope of a merger?
 
What exactly does "ECNL caliber" mean? Not every girls ECNL team is in the top 30 nationally. Yes, girls ECNL is top heavy with highly ranked teams. But, they also have their fair share of bottom feeders. Also it depends on which ECNL league you're talking about. Some are all quality, some aren't.

What ECNL has done is pick off some of GAs top clubs. If GA doesnt answer this spring converting top ECNL clubs to GA the writing is on the wall for GA. Its just a matter of time for things to play out.
It's already been played out. Top ECNL clubs are not converting to GA. It's over.
 
One of TopHat's leaders is(was) the vice president of the executive board of GA, 2nd in command. He was just removed from GA's website, even though he still shows up on google cache. He had to know everything that GA was planning to thrive and grow - that was his job - yet TopHat instead chose to get out of dodge.
That definitely appears to be a huge red flag for the GA
 
It's already been played out. Top ECNL clubs are not converting to GA. It's over.
You dont know this.

Almost everyone that posts here seems to be on the girls side. But clubs are boys and girls. If GA and MLSN are a package deal some ECNL clubs might jump at the opportunity.

We'll see what happens this spring.
 
Almost everyone that posts here seems to be on the girls side. But clubs are boys and girls. If GA and MLSN are a package deal some ECNL clubs might jump at the opportunity.

We'll see what happens this spring.
This was a reasonable belief over a year ago. The MLSN/GA announcement was December 2024 (shown here). It was expecting to pull in marquee clubs the following season, for 2025/26. It very clearly didn't, and went over like a wet fart. GA has just lost its most significant clubs. There's no reason to believe that any reasonable ECNL organization is going to come over another year later. The fat lady may not yet be singing, but she's warming up in the green room.
 
Back
Top