Bad look for the GA

Looks like it will put an end to those hypothetical bar bets of how those top GA teams would fare against top ECNL teams, when they pretty soon get to play them directly. These clubs right now are currently ranked #9 (HTX), #25 (TopHat), and #94 (STA) among all listed girls clubs in the US. In some age groups, they show top 10 teams nationally, with many others within the top 50.
 
At a quick look, it appears the HTX and TopHat are the only GA clubs within the top 25 - someone please correct me if I missed one.

GA1.jpgGA2.jpg
 
Link to full press release on ECNL site. Here's a blurb from there:

Tophat SC has been the most successful club in the history of the Girls Academy, claiming U17 and U19 national championships last season, and six total championships since 2023. STA has qualified for three of the last four GA Champions Cups from the Northeast, claiming the 2025 U17 championship, finishing second in the 2026 U19 age group, as well as appearing in back-to-back national finals in 2024 and 2025. HTX has qualified for all five GA Champions Cups from the Frontier since 2021, and claimed the 2024 U19 championship. Beyond their historical success, to date in the 2026-27 season, the clubs collectively have seven teams in first place in their current divisions from U13-U18, and six additional teams in second place in these divisions.
 
Yea, if true not a good look for GA.

We'll have to see how things end up this spring. GAs last chance will be clubs that want MLSN + have to play their girls in GA.
 
I bet that once HTX starts playing in ECNL Texas conference, they'll start losing games and fall out of the top 25. They are probably beating up teams in GA.
They certainly will, but the real effect of this will be seen over the next couple of years. The two local ECNL clubs are loaded with girls developed by HTX that left purely to be in ECNL. Now they will be able to retain their younger talent and will grow in strength over the next couple of years. Will be into see how dynamics shift in that market.
 
Maybe I will. It would only take 2-3 big ECNL clubs to switch to GA for MLSN and the entire dynamic would change.

I do agree GA losing big clubs is a major issue.
Doctor: Hi patient! You look amazing! Over the past few years, we have removed both of your legs, one kidney, and half of your stomach. We then stapled 10 extra ear lobes all over your body to make up for those now missing body parts. Now, we are removing your heart and lungs. It's sort of a major issue, but you'll be fine.
 
Doctor: Hi patient! You look amazing! Over the past few years, we have removed both of your legs, one kidney, and half of your stomach. We then stapled 10 extra ear lobes all over your body to make up for those now missing body parts. Now, we are removing your heart and lungs. It's sort of a major issue, but you'll be fine.
 
I guess I hadn't realized it had slid to this point. Who are the top GA clubs left nationally? Lou Fusz? Michigan Jaguars? Elmbrook? It's hard to find a club remaining in the top #100 nationally. Here's a list of all U15 GA teams. Link to GA's main schedule.
Jags, Lou Fusz, City SC, FC United, Midwest United, Elmbrook, Lamorinda, Cincinnati United, Springfield, Coppermine, NEFC, Indy Premier, SJEB, and I’m sure a few others are all good clubs and have solid teams that could compete in the ECNL. A big problem is many of these clubs would be national contenders but tend to lose their best players to neighboring ECNL clubs once they hit 13/14 years old.
 
Right - I looked through all of those, and most of them are outside of the top 100 clubs, ranked by top team U11-U17. They are leading in their local GA brackets, but wouldn't expect to be competitive with decent teams outside of their relatively weak bubble. There's certainly nothing wrong with that, and there are plenty more teams/clubs further down on the totem pole that would be looking up and happy to trade spots. But it's no longer tenable for GA (or GA supporters) to claim that the league is on the same playing field with ECNL girls. There may have been an argument to make a few years back, but at this point it would take quite a bit of copium/delusion.
 
This was already posted in another thread (U15 girls teams), and more clearly lays out the differences in competitiveness between both leagues, and between teams within leagues. It does show, that at the very top end, GA still has some teams that can compete with ECNL. It sounds like they are progressively losing them.

girls national leagues.png
 
This was already posted in another thread (U15 girls teams), and more clearly lays out the differences in competitiveness between both leagues, and between teams within leagues. It does show, that at the very top end, GA still has some teams that can compete with ECNL. It sounds like they are progressively losing them.

View attachment 42412
Being very familiar with the GA U15’s City SC is the reigning GA National Champions and would realistically be somewhere between 5-7th place in the ECNL southwest conference behind Surf, Koge, Beach and Blues. Maybe a little better given if they were in ECNL they’d probably attract a few players unhappy with their current ECNL club. The teams I’m familiar with that are similar to their level in the U15 GA are Lamorinda, HTX, SJEB, FC United, Indy Premier, NEFC and the Jags. Cincinnati United was a phenomenal team the year before but lost some really great players to Ohio Premier and they fell off. After that there are a few teams that would land middle to lower but not the worst depending on conference (Beadling, Galaxy, Celtic, Midwest, SYC, Elmbrook) Teams with talent but have holes. Teams that lost players to ECNL teams, etc… after that the GA level really drops. It gets into RL territory and some more N1 level.
 
What I'm surprised at is that there is still a huge gulf between the number of coaches that attend GA vs. ECRL showcases. There are a lot of teams in ECRL and a lot of overlooked/undiscovered talent in ECRL. If I'm a coach of a lower level D1, D2 or D3 school I am hitting up ECRL games and combing for the best players there.
 
It's a mindset thing, for both the players as well as the coaches. Going to a GA event, the players present believe they are competing at the highest level available to them - and coaches have historically felt similarly. Going to an ECRL event, almost every player there knows that their club has determined that there is a higher level team available on ECNL that they haven't yet been able to break into. Coaches also know this. Objectively, the quality of the teams, and therefore the quality of the players available, overlap very closely. But GA is selling something that ECRL isn't, the reality is just becoming more evident over time.
 
Being very familiar with the GA U15’s City SC is the reigning GA National Champions and would realistically be somewhere between 5-7th place in the ECNL southwest conference behind Surf, Koge, Beach and Blues. Maybe a little better given if they were in ECNL they’d probably attract a few players unhappy with their current ECNL club. The teams I’m familiar with that are similar to their level in the U15 GA are Lamorinda, HTX, SJEB, FC United, Indy Premier, NEFC and the Jags. Cincinnati United was a phenomenal team the year before but lost some really great players to Ohio Premier and they fell off. After that there are a few teams that would land middle to lower but not the worst depending on conference (Beadling, Galaxy, Celtic, Midwest, SYC, Elmbrook) Teams with talent but have holes. Teams that lost players to ECNL teams, etc… after that the GA level really drops. It gets into RL territory and some more N1 level.
GA has been neck and neck in RL territory since is creation. It's the hard truth that the GA propagandists have been dodging and arguing about on here for years. TopHat has been the go to anecdotal argument the entire time.

Like it was stated before, the TopHat performance during the upcoming season in ECNL will show everybody where the top GA teams compare, and therefore where all the mid and low tier GA teams would be as well.

Spoiler alert. ECRL = GA in level of play and player talent. It's also going to expose the Soccer Ranking Apps failure to accurately rank cross league comparisons.
 
Back
Top