High School Forfeits

Do you know people who school choice to a particular high school so they can get on a good soccer team?
I would guess this happens, but it's probably pretty rare. From what I've been told (and observed), club soccer is considered the higher level competitive path, and HS soccer is more recreational and with varied skill levels. You're much more likely to be "seen" playing for a strong club team than playing for a strong HS team, and the expectation is that the strongest players will always be on strong club teams.

This is probably much more prevalent with other sports, where HS is effectively the most competitive league (maybe football, for example), and/or where external competitive leagues are not as common (eg: tennis). I cannot see most kids trying to go to a "good soccer high school", though; you're clearly better off playing MLSN-HD, for example, if you are at that level, and you want a path to college or pro (and in that case, you're not playing HS soccer anyway).
 
Interesting; have not seen this at all in my sphere (at least for soccer). Maybe just different groups of people.
Some People wanna play for their high school and win a trophy or get an individual honor. It’s not just about the college credential. Some people feel high school sports is part of the experience and the privates force you to do one unless you have a medical exemption (which is why cross country gets dumped into). But you are right those going d1/d2 recruitment need to do mls hg (or ecnl) and not just any team but an academy or top national. We had a kid last year at our private who was an academy kid senior already committed d1 who stepped back to play for the school. You have top flights that attract players that want the trophy. You have families like my coworker whose kids are blocked if they go to a school and won’t get the sports slot.

Football is a different beast. For many positions, Like club you have to go to particular high schools to get recruited. If you are a wr and your qb can’t pass you aren’t getting noticed, and vice versa if you are a qb and your wr drops the ball. Some position like lineman you get more flex if you look the part.
 
Last edited:
I’m asking because I’m pretty sure my kid will eventually choose the academic route. Playing for a good high school team and winning a trophy will serve as my return for spending all the time and money on club soccer and a closure for the soccer chapter of his life. I’m actually thinking to school choice him but he will have to decide if it’s worth leaving his friends for.
 
Some People wanna play for their high school and win a trophy or get an individual honor. It’s not just about the college credential. Some people feel high school sports is part of the experience and the privates force you to do one unless you have a medical exemption (which is why cross country gets dumped into). But you are right those going d1/d2 recruitment need to do mls hg (or ecnl) and not just any team but an academy or top national. We had a kid last year at our private who was an academy kid senior already committed d1 who stepped back to play for the school. You have top flights that attract players that want the trophy. You have families like my coworker whose kids are blocked if they go to a school and won’t get the sports slot.

Football is a different beast. For many positions, Like club you have to go to particular high schools to get recruited. If you are a wr and your qb can’t pass you aren’t getting noticed, and vice versa if you are a qb and your wr drops the ball. Some position like lineman you get more flex if you look the part.
I totally get the "wanting to play HS sports", and my HS kid is doing this also, for sure. I just don't know of any parents which are "HS shopping" for good teams, particularly for soccer, where HS results effectively mean nothing in terms of future opportunities. Absolutely participate, have fun, compete for the school, etc.; just pick schools for academics not sports, imho.
 
I’m asking because I’m pretty sure my kid will eventually choose the academic route. Playing for a good high school team and winning a trophy will serve as my return for spending all the time and money on club soccer and a closure for the soccer chapter of his life. I’m actually thinking to school choice him but he will have to decide if it’s worth leaving his friends for.
My office mate with the incoming 6th grader has the exact same problem: give up on soccer entirely and maybe find another sport, start looking for high schools (when they bought a house there to send him to that one) or clubmax him out the next 4 years and hope he catches up. Wishes someone had told him this earlier but at least now has a 3 year runway to decide
 
I totally get the "wanting to play HS sports", and my HS kid is doing this also, for sure. I just don't know of any parents which are "HS shopping" for good teams, particularly for soccer, where HS results effectively mean nothing in terms of future opportunities. Absolutely participate, have fun, compete for the school, etc.; just pick schools for academics not sports, imho.
Well two small specific examples: the top schools especially privates and charters in the open league and flight 1which do aggregate talent…and kids who aren’t good enough but want to play but blocked if they go to one of those schools. Also btw have known some girls in the simi/north valley who were gks and switched…eg 6-7 gks competing for slots where only 2 will get to play before senior year (whether better or politics) and 4 or 5 only get a teamslot so impression I have is it is more common for gks. My sons friend growing up played for a flight 2 public and his highest level was a championship flight 1 SoCal club…he only made varsity senior year and had limited minutes. So it’s definitely getting worse out there.
 
Last edited:
I’m asking because I’m pretty sure my kid will eventually choose the academic route. Playing for a good high school team and winning a trophy will serve as my return for spending all the time and money on club soccer and a closure for the soccer chapter of his life. I’m actually thinking to school choice him but he will have to decide if it’s worth leaving his friends for.
Probably your kid will try both freshman year and depending on how he does in soccer and robotics, that will influence his decision on which to spend time on. If he is the top player on the soccer team, that would be big ego boost and would be hard for him to give up. Maybe he can do both since HS soccer is only one season.
 
FWIW IME soccer is a sufficiently commodity sport that there is less school shopping than in some other sports where quality ahtletes are hard to find. Speaking only for the sports with which I have personal experience, in SoCal WaterPolo kids absolutely pick schools based on the team given how concentrated the talent is. Football players frequently do the same for the reasons mentioned above (my son's QB brought his top receiver with him when they moved together to our school). I have not seen nearly as much movement between publics for soccer, but there are certainly privates that are targeted for their soccer program (e.g., Saints in SD which has siphoned off several of the top Albion kids in recent years and sent them on to D1).
 
Probably your kid will try both freshman year and depending on how he does in soccer and robotics, that will influence his decision on which to spend time on. If he is the top player on the soccer team, that would be big ego boost and would be hard for him to give up. Maybe he can do both since HS soccer is only one season.
School choice onto an open division school might actually be trickier than I thought now that I read more about it. The perennial open division schools are mostly private schools and public schools rotate in and out. In other words I can school choice in Jan into an open division public school and by the time the school starts it could already been knocked out of the open division.
 
Yes, this. As far as I can tell, if it's listed on CIF, it counts, and if not, it doesn't.
Thanks for the pointer; I was not previously aware of this site. However, seems like it can't be fully relied upon. My son's HS match last night (which the coach announced was only a scrimmage at the field despite the refs and scoreboard and fans and...) is not listed when I search for his team, but when I search for the opponent it shows up!?
 
From what I saw last year, there seemed to be quite a number of kids playing in MLS Next Academy teams who went to Next Fest in December while playing for their HS teams. Coaches didn't seem to care.
 
From what I saw last year, there seemed to be quite a number of kids playing in MLS Next Academy teams who went to Next Fest in December while playing for their HS teams. Coaches didn't seem to care.
This is what I noticed.
Not sure if because it wasn't a league game or what, but i'd say all the AD kids are playing both through early next month.
 
Thanks for the pointer; I was not previously aware of this site. However, seems like it can't be fully relied upon. My son's HS match last night (which the coach announced was only a scrimmage at the field despite the refs and scoreboard and fans and...) is not listed when I search for his team, but when I search for the opponent it shows up!?
What happened last year is when the teams advanced to the playoffs opponents (whether who had played them or those they were playing) ratted them out causing an investigation and then they were disqualified from the playoffs for rule breaking. In this case if your opponent is showing it, they’ll totally point to that as an “interscholastic competition” plus the ads, refs and score board. Busted…not much of a judgment call needs to be made. It’s why lots of schools avoid pre season scrimmages. Rivals even if they find out now may not bust you now but hold it to get teams playoff disqualified, which is what happened last year.

From what I saw last year, there seemed to be quite a number of kids playing in MLS Next Academy teams who went to Next Fest in December while playing for their HS teams. Coaches didn't seem to care.
Same this is even easier because mls has rosters. They can get an ai to do it and compared hs records. Some teams may not care if they can’t make playoffs. Last year became issues after season hit playoffs and most of the incidents happened because of flex or post thanksgiving ecnl tournaments. Guess we’re in for another round this year.
 
Same this is even easier because mls has rosters. They can get an ai to do it and compared hs records. Some teams may not care if they can’t make playoffs. Last year became issues after season hit playoffs and most of the incidents happened because of flex or post thanksgiving ecnl tournaments. Guess we’re in for another round this year.
This was my assumption/guess as to how it would play out as well. If teams don't make the playoffs, then few people care: nobody checks, cause the team isn't good enough to matter regardless. If a HS team makes playoff, then it's increasingly likely someone on their opponent's team/side does a quick AI-assisted search, and if the team has club players who broke the rules, then they can't play in the playoffs, the team forfeits games, and likely forfeits their playoff birth also, and the opponent team advances for free.

... and honestly, aside from some HS coaches potentially being in the dark about player eligibility, and the rest of the HS teammates maybe feeling screwed over by the selfishness of the club players, that situation is more/less fine, imho. If a garbage team plays ineligible players intentionally so that games are more competitive, that seems less bad to me than more lopsided blowouts. Hopefully increased league and roster transparency will allow HS coaches to make an informed decision there, and decide if they essentially want to be eligible for playoffs or not. Probably a spicy take, but whatever.
 
This was my assumption/guess as to how it would play out as well. If teams don't make the playoffs, then few people care: nobody checks, cause the team isn't good enough to matter regardless. If a HS team makes playoff, then it's increasingly likely someone on their opponent's team/side does a quick AI-assisted search, and if the team has club players who broke the rules, then they can't play in the playoffs, the team forfeits games, and likely forfeits their playoff birth also, and the opponent team advances for free.

... and honestly, aside from some HS coaches potentially being in the dark about player eligibility, and the rest of the HS teammates maybe feeling screwed over by the selfishness of the club players, that situation is more/less fine, imho. If a garbage team plays ineligible players intentionally so that games are more competitive, that seems less bad to me than more lopsided blowouts. Hopefully increased league and roster transparency will allow HS coaches to make an informed decision there, and decide if they essentially want to be eligible for playoffs or not. Probably a spicy take, but whatever.
Like it. 👍 My only note is after last year and the lecture they got from cif this year, no hs coach unless they are new is blind. Every coach has been educated to tell players and families the consequences and ramifications. Now I can see a player and family lying to the hs coach about their participation in maybe the final league game. But they have to be turning a blind eye if player missing practices due to flex or ecnl travel or the “scrimmage” which is advertised as a game or players missing practices to go to club practice.
 
Back
Top