The BEST!Keeps the shin guards in place, provides some protection to the outside of the leg, and the ankle ball joint, and is a cloth barrier with the shin: http://www.storelli.com/soccer-leg-guard
These actually worked for my DD:
https://www.amazon.com/Silver-Lined-Guard-Soccer-Model/dp/B012W70AVM
And, my DD and her teammates rarely wear shinguards at practice. They only put them on if they are going to be having a scrimmage.
What happened to "practice like you play"?
Try telling that to 15-18 year old and college players.
I assume the coach will tell them.
It's not cool to wear shin guards unless you are playing an actual game. At least that's what the mentality seems to be among olders. Some youngers occasionally as well. Until you see the errant swing and a miss of the ball and smack into the unprotected shin. What follows is the limp n hobble move for a few minutes while the pain subsides. Sometimes they learn from it..sometimes they don't. A former coach for one of my kids said no shin guards=no playing..regardless if it's a game or training. He was a good coach and didn't want to see anyone injured. Makes all the sense in the world.What happened to "practice like you play"?