The Driver
PREMIER
Wait what?
SCDSL Flights?
- Thread starter Allez les Bleus
- Start date
I suppose players might have switched teams, but I don't see a big impact on G02 in terms of the teams. Consider the following Development Academy Clubs:
Albion SC U-16/17 Not SCDSL (CSL)
Beach Futbol Club U-16/17 Looks like their top Flight 1 team (one of SCDSL's best) went DPL
Eagles Soccer Club U-16/17 Not SCDSL (CSL)
LA Galaxy San Diego U-16/17 Not SCDSL (CSL)
LA Galaxy U-16/17 Looks like their top SCDSL team (LA Galaxy South Bay Girls 2002 Elite) is returning to Flight 1
LAFC Slammers U-16/17 Hard to tell but looks like all Slammers best Flight 1 teams returned.
Legends FC U-16/17 Looks like 2 top Legends teams left Flight 1
Los Angeles Premier Futbol Club U-16/17 Not SCDSL (CSL)
Pateadores U-16/17 Best Flight 1 teams returned
Real So Cal U-16/17 Seems best Flight 1 teams returned
SC del Sol U-16/17 Arizona team
San Diego Surf U-16/17 Seems best Flight 1 teams returned
So Cal Blues Soccer Club U-16/17 Lost better of 2 Flight 1 teams; but may have moved some of the better players to the other Flight 1 team.
West Coast Futbol Club U-16/17 Same Flight 1 teams returns
So, in summary, it looks like SCDSL G02 Flight 1 lost one good Beach team, 2 good Legends teams, and one good So Cal Blues team that are Development Academy clubs. That's 4 out of the 40 flight 1 teams from 2016. Not exactly the end of the world. But, of course, it will ultimately depend on player movement more than team movement.
With all due respect, team name returning is meaningless because the players within those team move on, as you've also noted.
Keep in mind that teams don't make DA, players do. So the team continues on but players with abilities go to what's best for them.
While there are teams that stay together and ignore all the noise, most do not...
Simisoccerfan
PREMIER
Team names might stay the same but remember that doesn't mean they have the same players. Also:
- Beach, Legends, Pateadores, and Real - These teams will not have their second best teams in SCDSL. They will be in the DPL.
- Albion, Eagles, LA Galaxy San Diego, LA Premier - These teams will not have their second best teams in CSL. They will be in the DPL.
- LA Galaxy is not LA Galaxy South Bay.
- Slammers, So Cal Blues, West Coast, and San Diego Surf - These clubs have both DA and ECNL. This will pull players from the top SCSDL teams.
- Del Mar Sharks - New ECNL club will pull players.
jpeter
PREMIER
In the same token you can't assume or generalize that 2nd teams will be in DPL either, 3rd or 4th teams in that league in some cases from what I heard from 2 others.
When the dust settles around next year everyone will have a better idea on what's really what.
Simisoccerfan
PREMIER
I would be very surprised if any of the clubs are treating DPL as the third or fourth team. I have first hand knowledge with three of the clubs and secondary information from two more that DPL is the second team (though they may not yet be playing well since many of the girls are new to each other). What are the specifics you are hearing from others?
The Driver
PREMIER
Simisoccerfan
PREMIER
Explain your thoughts
The Driver
PREMIER
DPL just another league. Parents aren't buying that 1st 2nd 3rd team junk because it's the same hustle from last year... It's just the new and has bells. Can you list the coaches for DPL? Let's start with the 03s and work our way up. Last year was the first year of ECNL for the 03s can you name those coaches and did they switch to DPL or DA? It's the same girls and the same size ball.
We don't need to over complicate this. If your dd is a stud, has her heart set on playing in college & is willing to treat soccer like a job, she will be playing DA. DPL/DAII, ECNL, SCDSL Flight 1 will all be competing for the other girls. If you throw the DPL/DAII, ECNL & SCDSL flight 1 teams into a giant tournament it would probably be pretty even competition overall. Lots of gaming circuits because people want to control their piece of the pie. Why would a DPL/DAII or ECNL team even play against anyone else? If they lost it owed expose it for what it is (a non-DA flight 1 team); club DOCs aren't going to have that.
The people I feel bad for are the people that think DPL/DAII is something special. DPL/DAII girls & families will eventually realize that it isn't a path to DA; it is merely a way for the clubs to sell the families on the idea that their kid is on the cusp of DA. Almost there, almost there, almost there.
The people I feel bad for are the people that think DPL/DAII is something special. DPL/DAII girls & families will eventually realize that it isn't a path to DA; it is merely a way for the clubs to sell the families on the idea that their kid is on the cusp of DA. Almost there, almost there, almost there.
Good points simisoccerfan, Ive added a few thoughts:
- Beach, Legends, Pateadores, and Real - These teams will not have their second best teams in SCDSL. They will be in the DPL.
- I agree as to Beach and Legends. On paper I'm not sure about Pateadores and Real. The Pateadores top team from last year (Pateadores - Irvine G2002 - Ickes) is back with the same coach. They've done reasonably well in summer tournaments so looks like they still have decent talent. Same for Real So Cal - SCV (Mitrovitch).
- Albion, Eagles, LA Galaxy San Diego, LA Premier - These teams will not have their second best teams in CSL. They will be in the DPL.
- Since this thread is about SCDSL Flight 1, I didn't take time to analyze the CSL, but, if true, I suspect such changes could disproportionately impact the Premier division there.
- LA Galaxy is not LA Galaxy South Bay.
- The LA Galaxy South Bay website refers to the Academy program as "our LA Galaxy Academy." So they are representing to parents they are the same. http://www.lagalaxysouthbay.com/Programs/YearRoundTeams/index_E.html In any event, if there were no such connection then there would be LESS of a chance of the Galaxy's DA team negatively impacting SCDSL Flight 1.
- Slammers, So Cal Blues, West Coast, and San Diego Surf - These clubs have both DA and ECNL. This will pull players from the top SCSDL teams.
- I acknowledged player movement was a separate issue. However, I presume DA would draw from all over, not necessarily the specific club the DA team is housed in. DAII (or DPL as they call it) would seem more likely to pull a whole team out of SCDSL or CSL. That's the mystery right now.
- Del Mar Sharks - New ECNL club will pull players.
- This is a good point. Taking a closer look, it appears the Sharks moved their A team up to ECNL and now has their B team in Flight 1 of the SCDSL. However, I've seen players dual-carded between ECNL and Flight 1 so the Sharks' new Flight 1 team may have some of the club's better talent at its disposal.
U
uburoi
Guest
My DD's flight 1 team took apart a DPL team recently. No one knew it was a DPL team. We saw it after. Every club and team and coach is different. I have another kid in DA. It's just different but I'm not saying better. Every situation is unique. Do what works for you. Don't believe the hype or elitist parents. They ruin it for everyone.
bababooey
GOLD
I agree with most of what you say here. As for the studs that have their hearts set on college soccer and are willing to treat soccer like a job, those players may end up with an ECNL team so they can play HS soccer. Probably not many girls in this boat, but there are multiple girls that will take the ECNL path over the full DA path.
But my dd's coach and girls academy director stated that DPL will be something special?!? Now you are making me question our decision. ***This is a joke. I realize the intent of your comment.
As I have stated before and others have as well, the DPL league was created so that the DA clubs (without ECNL) had a place to put their reserve teams while trying to make it seem like an exclusive club (league). It's not elite or exclusive, but rather another way for these clubs to keep more of our money. I don't fault the clubs for doing this. Soccer is a business and they are capitalists.
If I am not mistaken LA Galaxy San Diego has moved to SCDSL
Simisoccerfan
PREMIER
Not per their website nor the list of flight teams at SCSDL.
I was 10 for 11. That 2003 team that is playing up (San Diego Soccer Club G2003 Academy Navy) was given a spot instead of Beach FC - South Bay G02 Torres. Interesting.
https://scdslsoccer.demosphere-secure.com/club-directory/2017-flights/
Simisoccerfan
PREMIER
Meaning all boys teams except one 2005 girls team.
GKDad65
SILVER ELITE
I still don't understand this "DPL/DAII" thing.
DPL is just another league put together by a few coaches/clubs to generate interest and INCOME.
What does it have to do with US Soccer?
So you're still believing that if the team name and the coach is the same, the player roster is the same?
Think of it this way. The team name is the label and the coach is the label holder. What the label gets stuck onto can be completely different. You cannot make the statement (you maybe right, btw) that they are the same until you see the roster. The actual players playing the games.
LAG is not LAGSB/OC/SD as the latter are all franchise organization with its own 501(C)3 charter and its own board of directors. They are licensing LAG name for fee. But LAG (not LAGSB) and LAGSD do have GDAs and they are new so they will draw from everywhere.
Since this thread is going back and forth on this particular aspect, I checked out the SCDSL website for club team listing. Its clear that the clubs with DPL has far less teams enrolled in SCDSL this season than the last.
So, speculating this is probably too uncertain to have any validity. Once season starts, you'll see who's on the field and playing, and will have the ground truth. Meanwhile, just go with what you believe in....
You're right, I don't see them in CSL for 2017. I see their boys teams in SCDSL, but for the G02 girls it looks like their Premier team moved to DPL and their other two teams now play in SDDA.