mulliganmom
SILVER
@Mystery Train well said. Fostering a love of the game is so important. I also think waiting is underrated. Thank you.
Love of the game is so important. Not sure if my daughter loves soccer more, or the girls that she plays with. Good chance we will keep our whole team when we go from U14 to U15 next year. They do parties together, sleepovers, parents don't gripe or back stab and get along, and the team keeps improving. With almost all the girls starting High School next year, it will be interesting to see who continues to play and who may not. If we club jumped all the time I'm not sure what my daughters outlook would be. She is 13, still growing, just becoming a teenager, so I want her playing where she is happy.I think it is wise to wait. If you could compare the rosters of most current U17 ECNL/DA teams today to the rosters of those same teams back in U13, there would be A LOT of different names. I wish I had the energy and spare time to do a full study, but I'd guess that most of those teams only retain 4-5 players from their 14-18 player rosters in the U13 days, if that. Some players move from one high level team to another, but I think there is a massive attrition percentage that either drop out of soccer completely or simply maxed out early and get by-passed. At least half of the ECNL/DA rosters in my kids' age range today are made up of names that weren't on the "elite" teams in back in U13. Her old club, which is now a DA club, doesn't have a single kid on their '02 DA team that was on their top team back when she was 12. Waiting is underrated, IMHO. If she sticks with it and matures and keeps the love of the game and is good enough, there will be plenty of opportunities on top level teams when she's older.
Love of the game is so important. Not sure if my daughter loves soccer more, or the girls that she plays with. Good chance we will keep our whole team when we go from U14 to U15 next year. They do parties together, sleepovers, parents don't gripe or back stab and get along, and the team keeps improving. With almost all the girls starting High School next year, it will be interesting to see who continues to play and who may not. If we club jumped all the time I'm not sure what my daughters outlook would be. She is 13, still growing, just becoming a teenager, so I want her playing where she is happy.
Not thinking about college yet as she is an 06. Trying to figure out if getting into a “more competitive” league now is worthwhile or waiting another year or two and letting her play more and develop before we start pushing the ECNL/DA/DPL angle.
Find a practice location that's close to home (for us it means <20 minutes since we have choices near where we live), a coach and teammates that SHE likes, and a team playing at her appropriate level (she is not the #1 starter or the #17 bench warmer). If you end up with Pep Guardiola after applying these requirements, awesomeNot thinking about college yet as she is an 06. Trying to figure out if getting into a “more competitive” league now is worthwhile or waiting another year or two and letting her play more and develop before we start pushing the ECNL/DA/DPL angle.
If I was the US Soccer Development Academy - I would put an immediate stop to the DPL or any other version of a DA 2 league.
If US soccer wants the best players in the academy system and wants everyone to adopt their rules (no high school play, 4 days a week, 10 month season, stop playing silly tournaments, etc) - Then they need to force their member clubs to do this.
I have recently talked with 2 parents who have kids that are playing "up" on a DPL team. They are doing this so that they can still play high school soccer and get an occasional look by playing on their appropriate age group's DA team as a designated player.
I'm sure there are several others that are using this loophole. (Not really my problem I guess. And I should probably just mind my own business).
My kids plays on a DPL team. There are pluses and minuses (disparity of competition being one of the main issues). If US Soccer passes that rule then I believe that you would see an upheaval of players at the clubs. The ability to play HS soccer is one of the main pluses at this time.If I was the US Soccer Development Academy - I would put an immediate stop to the DPL or any other version of a DA 2 league.
If US soccer wants the best players in the academy system and wants everyone to adopt their rules (no high school play, 4 days a week, 10 month season, stop playing silly tournaments, etc) - Then they need to force their member clubs to do this.
I have recently talked with 2 parents who have kids that are playing "up" on a DPL team. They are doing this so that they can still play high school soccer and get an occasional look by playing on their appropriate age group's DA team as a designated player.
I'm sure there are several others that are using this loophole. (Not really my problem I guess. And I should probably just mind my own business).
You are correct. But US Soccer could say "If you want to keep DA status, you won't be able to field any teams in leauges like DPL/DA2/ETC"The DA2/DPL league is independent of US Soccer/USSDA. It is a Cal South league where players are assigned player cards. In essense it would be the same as any other league, it just so happens the DA clubs got together and decided “hey let’s create a league where we only play each other and control the schedule and the rules.”
So really, the scenario you presented is no different than if each club had their second team in a different league. There is no loophole.
I have one daughter on 02 Legends DPL and one on 04 OC Surf DPL and here's my feedback. DPL has done nothing to promote college recruitment. I'm not impressed with the competition. I find that CRL and national league are much better leagues and much better competition. In fact, at this last weekend's Vegas showcase we had many coaches show up but only because of our individual player efforts. Our biggest turnout (20 coaches) was from playing another National League team. DPL needs to get better competition or it ain't worth it.
Secondly, we played at Eagles a few weeks ago and Real So Cal today and the fields were atrocious. I wouldn't let my AYSO teams from many years ago play on them. Gopher holes and long grass made the game just kickball. Even the refs were complaining. One of our girls today fell in dog poop. She laughed at it but that just confirms the level of commitment this league has to the girls by giving us such a field. I asked my 04 daughter why she wasn't running fast and she said "because I was stepping in holes". How can a league survive with these conditions. Not sure if that was a league issue or a club issue but come on folks. We drove 2 hours for that? No sour grapes either as we won both games by over 6 goals each.
our team played in Vegas and had about 25 coaches come watch the games. There was a lot of work by a dad on our team working with the girls to send emails prior. There has been nice follow up as well since we have been back. And we are DPLI have one daughter on 02 Legends DPL and one on 04 OC Surf DPL and here's my feedback. DPL has done nothing to promote college recruitment. I'm not impressed with the competition. I find that CRL and national league are much better leagues and much better competition. In fact, at this last weekend's Vegas showcase we had many coaches show up but only because of our individual player efforts. Our biggest turnout (20 coaches) was from playing another National League team. DPL needs to get better competition or it ain't worth it.
Secondly, we played at Eagles a few weeks ago and Real So Cal today and the fields were atrocious. I wouldn't let my AYSO teams from many years ago play on them. Gopher holes and long grass made the game just kickball. Even the refs were complaining. One of our girls today fell in dog poop. She laughed at it but that just confirms the level of commitment this league has to the girls by giving us such a field. I asked my 04 daughter why she wasn't running fast and she said "because I was stepping in holes". How can a league survive with these conditions. Not sure if that was a league issue or a club issue but come on folks. We drove 2 hours for that? No sour grapes either as we won both games by over 6 goals each.
Anyway to message directly? Just wanted to ask about JMU years etc without gumming up the thread...Sounds like you were playing at Valle Lindo due to the rain. The field sucks. The Pleasant Valley fields are some of the nicest grass fields anywhere. Those are the main Eagles fields.
Anyway to message directly? Just wanted to ask about JMU years etc without gumming up the thread...
My thoughts of DPL where my 03 DD played up with the club’s 02 DPL team. First, her team trains alongside the DA team which Made it very competitive. More so than some of their DPL games. Their Thur training consist of round robin short games between the DA & DPL teams. As a keeper, multiple keeper training days alongside her team’s training session. As a keeper pops, I love it so I don’t have to take another trip.
The opportunity of playing HS this fall was enjoyable for her and the family. Yes, level of play was not the same but it gave her the chance to touch the ball more than her club games. The only negative was too many games in the weeks leading to league games. As they get older resting their body is important.
Our showcase and National League games attracted as many as 35 college coaches per games. We have had multiple girls with verbal commitment. Our club college pathway is definitely a cut above (my opinion).
Yes, it’s not DA but no regrets as a parent. She missed the season before due to ACL injury so this season gave her a good window to get back playing at a very competitive level.
Remember before DA, clubs used EGSL as their 2nd top tier team. LMAO
Honest question- if she is playing up a year on DPL- why not play in her actual age group on DA? (And I know of several others girls in various age groups doing the same thing).
Question #2- has she had any “call ups” to the DA team? (I think DPL was billed as a feeder to DA)
DPL is not what I thought it would be. Competition is not as competitive and no better than SCDSL Discovery or Tier 1. It offers zero visibility to DA program. Zero benefits. No real standing. No end of season playoffs. You have to travel to AZ for meaningless games also all over SoCal. I am not sure what is the purpose of this DPL. I would recommend ECNL and skip DPL since the kids who are talented but do not want to practice 4 days/wk and still want to play HS will be playing ECNL. Left over players (non-DA and ECNL) go to DPL or SCDSL or CSL. Unless you are into patch, then DP looks pretty cool and similar to DA.Now that the 1st season of DPL is done. Any thoughts about DPL?
Thinking about next season for my DD and wondering if we should look for a club that has an ECNL team vs DPL offer vs flight 1 A team with a good coach?
You guys come out exactly for one weekend be it DA, ECNL or DPL. That is not a tough travel schedule.You have to travel to AZ for meaningless games also all over SoCal.
Here in SoCal we have a lot of elite teams competing in DA and ECN; DPL is pretty much relegated to being an after thought. I think some clubs do a better job of promoting DA2 and DA programs while other clubs treat DA2 like another regular team.
What was sold to me two years ago was that DA2 would train along side with DA, and they would get to travel and play in the same showcases as DA for the better college exposure.
Don't get me wrong I think scouts will still come out to watch DPL games at college showcases but the exposure is not any better than if they play for a top team in a regular SCDSL or CSL.