Integrity Issue - Should it Matter?

I agree with almost everything above. Joysticking sucks. The worst is when coaches are screaming all game. Players should be good enough to wait for instruction at half or at training. But then @Jamisfoes brought up a good counter point on coach getting fired for not coaching enough in-game.

I don't think most parents understand how tough coaching really is. The same applies to ref'ing and playing. I think all soccer parents should coach for a team where results matter and your job is on the line, do some refereeing for 11 v 11 games and play soccer in 90 deg heat at Norco. Their perspectives will change after having to go through it.
Excellent points. I happen to love a joysticking coach for my kids, but I can understand why development might be better with other methods.

But to your other points: I had a good friend who told me a story about how his dad would constantly chastise his mistakes (this was badminton) and he resented his dad greatly for it. This friend of mine finally got to his teen years and asked his dad, "ok, show me how to do it" and challenged him to a game. He described beating his dad so bad that he was embarrassed for him. His dad never said another word.
I remembered that story when I started coaching my kids, so at the same time I began coaching I joined up with weekend pickup games, so that I could understand the game better (there was no soccer in my area as a kid). What I learned is how VASTLY MORE DIFFICULT SOCCER IS THAN IT LOOKS. Same with reffing! Same with coaching.
 
Back
Top