Again mischaracterizes what I'm saying. NY and NJ are just an example of what happens when you scream shark and overreact to a situation which makes the situation far worse. Those states actions were in direct contradiction to what the guidance from the CDC was. Now I'll will grant you that because NY was hit first they were to some extent a victim of timing (I mentioned that in another thread) but there were also other factors like NY (particularly NYC) having the worst rated hospitals for quality and safety in the US due to State budget cuts.
Certainly emotion and anecdotal information plays a roll in shaping our opinions. Anecdotally for me, I directly know 2 people during this time period that have OD'd or committed suicide (one adult, one teenager), one teenager that attempted suicide, and one teenager at our high school that committed suicide. On the other hand, I only know 2 people directly that have had Covid (only with flu like symptoms) and a friend of a friend that was hospitalized with Covid. I also have an 88 year old mom with co-conditions who says being on lockdown and not seeing her grandchildren is not living...so she sees her grandchildren on a fairly regular basis. So that's my emotional perspective...now let's look at the facts.
Dr. Birx said from the beginning that we have to look at and fight the virus on a "granular", or county by county basis. So let's look at SD County where I live. Its done a tremendous job despite the fact that its a border town where many of the cases have originated. Overall only .097% of the population has been hospitalized being Covid positive, and only .022% have died as Covid positive. Those percentages decrease dramatically the younger you are. This is worst case scenario since it doesn't consider cause of death from comorbidities. Covid is serious, but its not the boogieman that some are making it out to be whether out of fear, or out of the power to control people's behavior.
| | Hospitalized | | Deaths | |
| SD | Covid | % of | Covid | % of |
Age Group | Population | Positive | Pop. | Positive | Pop. |
0-9 Years | 433,599 | 43 | 0.010% | - | 0.000% |
10-19 Years | 433,694 | 48 | 0.011% | - | 0.000% |
20-29 Years | 530,918 | 194 | 0.037% | 3 | 0.001% |
30-39 Years | 490,007 | 282 | 0.058% | 5 | 0.001% |
40-49 Years | 399,146 | 355 | 0.089% | 28 | 0.007% |
50-59 Years | 404,442 | 605 | 0.150% | 61 | 0.015% |
60-69 Years | 340,330 | 676 | 0.199% | 131 | 0.038% |
70-79 Years | 199,891 | 514 | 0.257% | 162 | 0.081% |
80+ Years | 119,827 | 534 | 0.446% | 335 | 0.280% |
Total | 3,351,856 | 3,251 | 0.097% | 725 | 0.022% |