Mine have been to these camps as well as other "open access" ID camps and some invite only small-group camps. My take on the SM camps is that the level of comp at these camps is very variable, making for some rough scrimmages with potentially chaotic play (lots of ball hogging, 1v1, and non-tactical soccer) that makes them a crap shoot. The D1 and Ivy coaches have basically said at these camps that they're not expecting to find much. In their words, the number of open spots they're filling is limited and SM camps aren't the pipeline for these prospects. They might find a hidden green but the coaches are going more as a service and side gig than to find recruits. Moreover, the amount of time players are actually playing/active in front of coaches is not huge relative to the amount of time you spend there. For example, at one of the SM camps we went to, kids were playing/training/warming-up in front of coaches for a total of 3 hours in a day that went from 8:30am to 5pm (8.5 total hours). In those 3 hours, players were rotating, subbing, etc. so the actual amount of exposure was even less. Lots of dead time watching other groups play, taking breaks, having lunch, etc. So, if your kid isn't a standout at the camp they won't be much of a beneficiary from the name recognition value in the follow up communications. And if they are a standout, the coach should already know who they are by junior year. And, of they aren't juniors the coaches can't even talk to them anyway.