AFTER MAGA: A LETTER TO MY REPUBLICAN FRIENDS
By Reginald Milton
As a lifelong Democrat, one of my proudest memories was during my eight years as a Shelby County Commissioner, I had the honor to work alongside many Republicans. We disagreed, sometimes passionately, but I came to know many as decent, honorable people. People I respected. People I still consider friends today.
And it is to those friends that I write this letter.
I wonder how many of you look at what has become of your party and quietly ask yourselves, How in God’s name did we get here?
I look at this battered, torn MAGA hat lying on the ground, and I see something far greater than a discarded piece of clothing. I see the wreckage of a political movement that has consumed the party so many of you once believed in.
But this didn’t begin with Donald Trump. The roots run much deeper.
They stretch back more than 160 years, to the betrayal of Reconstruction, when a nation that had just fought a bloody Civil War failed to protect the freedom it had promised millions of formerly enslaved Americans. President Andrew Johnson helped undermine Reconstruction, and by 1877, the withdrawal of federal troops from the South helped open the door to generations of Jim Crow, segregation, and racial terror.
A century later, when the Civil Rights Movement finally began tearing down those walls, another backlash emerged. The Republican Party’s Southern Strategy capitalized on racial resentment, and the rise of the Moral Majority helped forge a powerful alliance between conservative politics and evangelical Christianity.
Then came the Tea Party, fueled by anger at government, but also carrying a current of racial resentment that grew during the presidency of Barack Obama.
And finally came MAGA.
Donald Trump did not invent these divisions. He recognized them, exploited them, and turned them into a political weapon.
What troubles me most is not simply what Trump has done. It is how many people who once knew better have chosen to remain silent.
I think about Republicans like John McCain and Mitt Romney. Men with whom I certainly would have disagreed on many issues, but who demonstrated, at critical moments, that loyalty to country and conscience could come before loyalty to party. We didn’t have to agree on everything to recognize that principle.
I know some of you see what is happening. I know some of you are uncomfortable with the cruelty, the attacks on our institutions, the embrace of conspiracy theories, and the willingness to turn Americans against one another.
And I cannot help but wonder what happened to the courage to stand up and say, Enough. This is not who we are.
There is something else we must confront.
America is changing. It is becoming more racially and culturally diverse. The America of tomorrow will not look like the America of yesterday.
And that frightens some people.
But the changing color of America is not a threat to our democracy. The fear of that change, and the willingness to destroy our democracy rather than accept it, is the real threat.
We have reached a moment of choosing.
We can embrace the extraordinary diversity of this nation and build something greater together, or we can continue down a road of resentment, suspicion, and hatred until there is nothing left holding us together.
And believe me, this nation cannot sustain this level of division forever.
My Republican friends, I am not asking you to become Democrats. I am not asking you to abandon your conservative principles. I am asking you to remember the principles that once made you proud to call yourselves Republicans.
There was a time when we could disagree about taxes, spending, education, and the role of government without questioning one another’s patriotism or humanity.
We were political opponents, not enemies.
I miss that America.
And I suspect many of you do, too.
But wishing for its return will not bring it back. Silence will not bring it back. Waiting for someone else to find the courage will not bring it back.
You must reclaim your party. You must demand leaders who understand that governing is not about vengeance, humiliation, or the endless pursuit of power. It is about serving a nation larger than any one man, any one race, or any one political party.
I do not believe every Republican has surrendered to what MAGA has become. I refuse to believe that the decent people I knew and worked alongside have simply disappeared.
But there comes a time when being a decent person is not enough. There comes a time when decency demands action.
History will not simply ask what you believed. It will ask what you did when you knew something was wrong.
And to my Republican friends, I say this with sincerity, not anger:
We need you. Our country needs you.
Not to agree with us on everything, but to stand with us on the one thing that must matter more than party.
The survival of this American democracy.
We need each other, whether we like it or not. Because in the end, this country belongs to all of us, and none of us can afford to watch it come apart.
And to my Democratic friends who have been sitting there nodding your heads in agreement, don’t get too comfortable. I’ve got plenty to say about what’s wrong with our party, too.
But that’s another letter. And believe me, it’s going to be a long one.