Girls Development Academy

Why is everyone confusing what I said? My statement was in reference to playing EGSL teams during our SCDSL season and a National Cup or 2. All of them were poor. They were the B teams. I was comparing DA team to the ECNL team at ECNL clubs. There is simply not enough talent in SoCal therefore the DA will be the 1st team and ECNL will be the 2nd team. Thus equal to the old EGSL. That is why I made the statement that ECNL in SoCal will be subpar. As far as DP and SD in Westwood? No dirty laundry here. My kid bleeds Trojan blood and she couldn't be happier. As far as National championships you of all people should know better. Just cause you have a roster of so and so is no guarantee. How many "great" teams have not won year after year? There are breaks and a little luck along the way that is required no matter how good you are especially in soccer and with such a short compacted season I think it gets multiplied.

No argument here. Who said anything about Westwood? I simply said that your daughter and SD should be playing with my daughter. I'm fine with her bleeding whatever the Trojans call their colors but do you disagree? I agree about getting the breaks being a part of winning a national championship but I feel pretty good about things right now and if Vegas were making the odds they would be 3 to 1 against the field. I would love to rehash this conversation come December. Good luck to your daughter and I look forward to seeing you on the sideline this season.
 
Unothat, I submit that GDA does have promotion and relegation.

The non-ECNL clubs that are "in" have been promoted to the most elite level available in the country. Clubs like Beach, Legends, Pats, LAPFC have been promoted de facto...

Also GDA has relegated some clubs...the ECNL clubs that were not invited to GDA have been relegated de facto as well...

Since clubs can apply to GDA it seems that from time to time clubs may be included and excluded based upon results and the financial fitness of the applicants...just speculation on my part but their platform seems to allow for promotion and culling in a way that was not so clear w the ECNL oligopoly...

There is no relegation in GDA. They haven't even put together the rules yet. Some clubs that were very undeserving in SoCal got GDA namely pretty much all of the non-ECNL clubs. Just look at their records. Zero national championships prior to the ECNL teams leaving and very few National team players. It's not that hard to win a national championship when most of the best teams and players aren't competing.
 

1544 players to received scholarships. Divide that by 70 academies and 4 age groups which works out to 22 scholarships per club and 5.5 scholarships per team or about 1/4 of the roster. So are they just going to scholarship the players that the coach considers "elite" or is it going to be a recruiting tool? Hey soccermom your Mia is going to get a full ride from us if you come over from (insert Surf, Blues or Slammers here). We will include all travel costs too! Are travel costs part of the scholarship? I like that they finally hired someone to lead this project even if it is only 5 months from kickoff. It would be nice if we got some specifics.
 
1544 players to received scholarships. Divide that by 70 academies and 4 age groups which works out to 22 scholarships per club and 5.5 scholarships per team or about 1/4 of the roster. So are they just going to scholarship the players that the coach considers "elite" or is it going to be a recruiting tool? Hey soccermom your Mia is going to get a full ride from us if you come over from (insert Surf, Blues or Slammers here). We will include all travel costs too! Are travel costs part of the scholarship? I like that they finally hired someone to lead this project even if it is only 5 months from kickoff. It would be nice if we got some specifics.

I did get this article right after the announcement

http://www.socceramerica.com/article/72347/girls-da-director-miriam-hickey-federation-is-bes.html
 


You have to read the comments at the bottom because they are spot on. I have a little trouble with this statement although it does have it's positives too:

SA: When you go to watch DA games, what will you be looking for?

MIRIAM HICKEY: There’s not one right way to play. Sometimes the team that plays the long ball wins the game. And at the top level, it’s about winning. But in youth development programs, it’s about players being able to recognize situations on the field. To be able to adjust what they’re doing and react to it and solve those soccer problems on their own without someone on the sidelines telling them what they need to do.

When I watch a team under pressure not use their goalkeeper to relieve pressure, and instead kicking the ball out of bounds to reset, that’s usually a sign that you have a coach who’s not developing their team.

If a goalkeeper makes a save and all she looks for is to punt it – she doesn’t look if there are opportunities to build out of the back -- that’s usually an indicator the team has not been given the opportunity to develop.

At 14 and 15, it’s already a little late. That needs to be taught when they’re 8, 9, 10. That’s when you don’t care if you get scored on five times -- as long as over the course of a year these players learn to recognize those situations.

For me, it’s a player’s game. I’m looking for coaches who inspire their players. Who let their players make decisions. Coaches who are giving information instead of, “Hey that was a good job” or just telling them what they did wrong.

I believe in short information and letting the game flow.
 
She was quoted, "pathway directly to professional clubs". Who in there right minds would have their DDs skip their college education for a NWSL salary? #yikes #cuckoo

MIRIAM HICKEY: What this program does is it simplifies the landscape. It also provides the pathway directly to professional clubs and the national youth teams … with U.S. Soccer being in charge
 
She was quoted, "pathway directly to professional clubs". Who in there right minds would have their DDs skip their college education for a NWSL salary? #yikes #cuckoo

MIRIAM HICKEY: What this program does is it simplifies the landscape. It also provides the pathway directly to professional clubs and the national youth teams … with U.S. Soccer being in charge


I agree. The starting median salary at my players school for grads is more than a max contract in the NWSL. She told me that she isn't even considering going pro. It's funny because she will be on Chris Henderson's top 25 draft prospects for 2020 that he is releasing in the next week and I will bet money that she is in the top 10.
 
I agree. The starting median salary at my players school for grads is more than a max contract in the NWSL. She told me that she isn't even considering going pro. It's funny because she will be on Chris Henderson's top 25 draft prospects for 2020 that he is releasing in the next week and I will bet money that she is in the top 10.
That will be awesome
 
I agree. The starting median salary at my players school for grads is more than a max contract in the NWSL. She told me that she isn't even considering going pro. It's funny because she will be on Chris Henderson's top 25 draft prospects for 2020 that he is releasing in the next week and I will bet money that she is in the top 10.

MAP, if your DD was an 03, what would you recommend, DA or ECNL? Or play 02 ECNL?
 
MAP, if your DD was an 03, what would you recommend, DA or ECNL? Or play 02 ECNL?

It depends upon the coach and the club. I can tell you that my player wouldn't give up high school. I tried to get her to do it and it worked for about 7 games then she missed it. Ask your daughter what she wants to do. Tell her the pros and cons and let her decide. Soccer girls are pretty smart. Then find her the best available coach at one of the clubs that has what she is looking for. Make sure to check the clubs record prior to 2009.
 
I agree. The starting median salary at my players school for grads is more than a max contract in the NWSL. She told me that she isn't even considering going pro. It's funny because she will be on Chris Henderson's top 25 draft prospects for 2020 that he is releasing in the next week and I will bet money that she is in the top 10.

Unless your DD plans to go straight to grad school or has another clear career path, your DD should take the contract if she still likes soccer. She and her friends won't be making that much coming out of UCLA without an additional degree. They'll struggle to get jobs at all - that's reality. Nationally, less than 15% of seniors have real jobs lined up. UCLA is around 30% employment, and that's six months after graduation (so query where you got the median salary info?). UCLA is also notoriously unethical about their job statistics, although most are bad. UCLA got really shady during the recession.

Have her play a couple of years while she figures out grad school. Most grad schools now don't want kids right out of school, so a few years playing would be perfect.
 
So again I will ask this again: If you live in a city or state where you cannot even get to a DA practice weekly, does that make you not elite? Lol thats bull and y'all know it. The only reason why So Cal is embracing it is because of population density. The parents of kids on current B teams think this is their ticket to finally be seen. This is laughable, the Miriam chick is a joke. And honestly, most girls on the youth national teams dont even make the full national team. So whats the point?

And yes I'm irritated by the whole thing.
 
Unless your DD plans to go straight to grad school or has another clear career path, your DD should take the contract if she still likes soccer. She and her friends won't be making that much coming out of UCLA without an additional degree. They'll struggle to get jobs at all - that's reality. Nationally, less than 15% of seniors have real jobs lined up. UCLA is around 30% employment, and that's six months after graduation (so query where you got the median salary info?). UCLA is also notoriously unethical about their job statistics, although most are bad. UCLA got really shady during the recession.

Have her play a couple of years while she figures out grad school. Most grad schools now don't want kids right out of school, so a few years playing would be perfect.

They will be making more than NWSL. It's absolutely ridiculous the salaries they pay these women. You could teach part time, or work at Walmart full time and make more money . You could coach youth soccer and

As a UCLA grad, my degrees have served me very well. For that matter, everyone I know did well. No struggles EVER staying employed . UCLA is about career paths not jobs.

If one wants to play NWSL by all means, go for it. The reality is until there is a livable wage for women's soccer, your better off beginning your career or post graduate program.
 
1544 players to received scholarships. Divide that by 70 academies and 4 age groups which works out to 22 scholarships per club and 5.5 scholarships per team or about 1/4 of the roster. So are they just going to scholarship the players that the coach considers "elite" or is it going to be a recruiting tool? Hey soccermom your Mia is going to get a full ride from us if you come over from (insert Surf, Blues or Slammers here). We will include all travel costs too! Are travel costs part of the scholarship? I like that they finally hired someone to lead this project even if it is only 5 months from kickoff. It would be nice if we got some specifics.
Only 4 of 70 clubs are fully funded 2 in Socal, so 1544 divide by 4 across all age groups give you all players in fully funded academies are now playing for free for at least next season.
 
Only 4 of 70 clubs are fully funded 2 in Socal, so 1544 divide by 4 across all age groups give you all players in fully funded academies are now playing for free for at least next season.

Agree it's not equal. There are fully funded girls I know as well in those specific clubs.
More commonly - as I have friends now who have been offered at four clubs they are getting fifty percent scholarships - basically playing for about 1$ k .
I don't know how this is being offered but I assume it's the usual backdoor politics.
Interestingly enough one smaller but prestigious club does not have the funds to do this and is having some difficulties.
 
Only 4 of 70 clubs are fully funded 2 in Socal, so 1544 divide by 4 across all age groups give you all players in fully funded academies are now playing for free for at least next season.

Again dependant. They haven't even set the regional showcase schedule up yet. I assume because there are so many clubs that travel would be limited actually.
From what I have seen with my stud friends they are getting full offers and then some. So far everyone has been very happy with the outcomes honestly I haven't heard a lot of dissent
 
I think that this article is better and it is by Anson Dorrance who actually won a World Cup and has coached 23 national championship teams at the D1 level.

http://www.socceramerica.com/article/72332/anson-dorrance-on-girls-da-vs-ecnl-and-why-the.html

This is a must read.

I do not know Hickey, but this quote from her is priceless and sums up the entire issue .. "The ECNL league, I understand, will continue and they will do their thing and we will do our thing …"

US Soccer only cares about "their thing," a focus on building the YNT, and has historically shown mostly disdain for the rest of the youth soccer landscape. So far, the Girls DA roll-out has been consistent with this attitude.

While I have been critical of the ECNL and their exclusion of certain clubs and its geographic distribution here in Socal, I will admit they do an excellent job of listening to and meeting the needs of all of their customers (college coaches, club DOC's and coaches, and players). That is the differentiation ECNL should continue to promote, as it will help them separate themsleves from the DA and provide a real alternative, not just more of the same.
 
Back
Top